New Books in Indian Religions · Marshall Poe

Karen Pechilis ed., "A Cultural History of Hinduism: Volumes 1-6" (Bloomsbury, 2024)

·1 hr·5 clips
Karen Pechilis shares how Bloomsbury Academic approached her to edit a groundbreaking six-volume cultural history of Hinduism.
The episode opens with a quick appeal for listeners to fill out the 2026 NewBooks Network audience survey. It then moves to Karen Pachilis's six-volume A Cultural History of Hinduism, with the editors presenting the project as an attempt to organize a vast, internally varied tradition without pretending the category is neat or simple. The conversation stays calm and measured. The speakers explain that Hinduism is still the best available label for a history that spans social orders, historical periods, and the broader culture and history of South Asia. Chronology gives the series its shape. The editors move through the collection volume by volume, starting with antiquity, and they describe the editorial decisions needed to mark where one period ends and the next begins. Those choices are not treated as neutral. Instead, the conversation keeps circling back to the fact that any history this broad has to decide what to highlight, what to set aside, and what can only appear through selection. The antiquity volume gets particular attention in the discussion. Its boundaries are described clearly, including the choice not to include the Indus Valley civilization there, which the editors present as one of the framing tradeoffs of the volume. That honesty gives the discussion more weight. Rather than presenting the series as complete, the guests treat its limits as part of what makes it a useful scholarly resource. Madhav Deshpande's final chapter comes up as an important piece. It is singled out as one of the global-context chapters, and the conversation notes how those chapters differ across the volumes. The series also sounds teachable. The editors keep returning to how readers, students, and nonspecialists can enter the material without flattening the field, which fits the show's patient interview style. The closing note stays modest. The conversation ends by thanking the editors, pointing listeners to the podcast notes, and leaving the sense that this is a reference project meant to be consulted slowly and revisited. The whole exchange remains careful. It treats Hinduism as a moving target, and the six-volume set as an effort to describe that movement with enough structure to be useful.

As heard by us

A measured look at Hinduism's scholarly framing, with its edges kept in view.

This episode treats the six-volume Hinduism project as a question of boundaries as much as coverage. The editors move through the Bloomsbury set with enough care to make the scale feel manageable, and the best passages are the ones that let editorial structure do the arguing.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Need a careful tour of a six-volume cultural history of Hinduism that treats the category as useful but still problematic?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on