New Books in Indian Religions · Marshall Poe

Jürgen Schaflechner, "Hinglaj Devi: Identity, Change, and Solidification at a Hindu Temple in Pakistan" (Oxford UP, 2018)

·1 hr 27 min·5 clips
How did a remote shrine in Balochistan unify Pakistan's Hindu castes through ancient Sanskrit texts?
The episode opens with Hinglaj Devi, a shrine in Pakistan. The discussion treats it as a place where history, pilgrimage, and interpretation are constantly being renegotiated. The interview explains that there are multiple traditions and narratives attached to the site. Those narratives do not always line up with one another. They often stay within different language communities. The episode shows how that plurality became harder to ignore once access to the shrine changed. When the Makran Coastal Highway was built in 2001, travel to the site became much easier. With that change, the annual meeting at the shrine expanded quickly. Attendance rose from about 40,000 people to well over 100,000. That growth brought different groups into closer contact. People who had previously held separate understandings of the shrine now met, talked, and disagreed in public. The interview emphasizes that many visitors were looking for the real tradition, the proper version, the one authentic way to worship there. That demand for certainty helped push the shrine toward a more fixed story. The Hinglaj Seva Mandali appears in the discussion as the organization that came to guide visitors and interpret the shrine. Its authority was not simply planned from above. It grew partly because the people associated with it lived close to the shrine and knew how to direct pilgrims to the site. That practical role gave them interpretive power. Over time, that power helped one narrative harden into the main account. The episode frames this as a solidification of the shrine. A place with many overlapping meanings begins to settle into a more singular public identity. The interview then broadens into Pakistan's religious and political landscape. It touches on the country's relationship to Israel and the unusual ways Jewish identity can emerge there. The speaker links the local story to a larger global pattern in which people across different religious backgrounds experience visions, awakenings, or shifts in self-understanding that lead them to identify as Jewish. That larger frame gives the book a comparative reach beyond one shrine or one nation. The interview ends by returning to the value of the work as a serious scholarly intervention into religion, identity, and change.

As heard by us

A careful study of how a shrine, a pilgrimage, and a tradition become more fixed over time.

Jürgen Schaflechner's book conversation keeps coming back to the Hinglaj Devi temple in Pakistan as a place where devotion, travel, and interpretation stay in motion.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want a conversation about how a shrine's meaning gets settled through travel, authority, and competing interpretations?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on