New Books in Indian Religions · Marshall Poe

Ashis Roy, "Intimacy in Alienation: A Psychoanalytic Study of Hindu-muslim Relationships" (Yoda Press, 2024)

·1 hr 2 min·5 clips
Ashis Roy explains how a dinner conversation about Hindu-Muslim coexistence sparked his book on forbidden love.
Tracy Morgan opens with Dr. Ashes Roy and the book. He and Roy discuss mixed-faith Hindu-Muslim relationships, keeping the focus on how couples make sense of their lives when familiar categories do not quite hold. The book's central tension is plain. Roy returns to the gap between intimacy and alienation as a way of naming both connection and distance inside these relationships. Recognition matters throughout. Roy says many couples were not looking for theory first but for acknowledgment of the struggle they were already carrying, especially when they lacked cultural resources for the questions in front of them. Children come up as well. Morgan presses on the question of religious identity for children, and Roy points out that even a well-meant answer like "the child can choose whatever they want to" does not make the problem simple. A Bihar case makes this concrete. Roy describes Sunan and Kasim, where the son wants identification with the Muslim father's religion even though the father is not religious, showing how family feeling, inheritance, and personal desire can move in different directions. The interview is not passive. Roy explains that, as a younger analytic researcher, he asked his own questions and tried to make couples think through their conflicts rather than just collecting statements from them. He also names empathy. He says he empathized deeply with the pain the couples described, and that sensitivity was part of the work rather than a sentimental layer on top of it. Suicidal history is discussed directly. Morgan asks about the subjects who had suicide attempts or suicidal ideation in their pasts, and Roy answers in the same careful register, keeping the conversation grounded in the book's human stakes. The closing section turns outward. Morgan notes that the book already has several reviews, including one in the British Journal of Psychotherapy, some in Indian media, one upcoming in Psychoanalysis, Culture and Society, and an interview on IPA Off the Couch. The episode ends on a hopeful note. Morgan says he hopes more readers will find the book, learn from it, and experience the study's mix of scholarly rigor and human recognition.

As heard by us

A measured conversation about mixed-faith relationships, recognition, and the difficulty of easy answers.

Dr. Ashes Roy turns a conversation about a book on Hindu-Muslim relationships into a close look at mixed-faith families and the pressure they carry.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a calm, psychoanalytic interview about mixed-faith family life and the pressure around identity.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on