New Books in Geography · Marshall Poe

Jen Rose Smith, "Ice Geographies: The Colonial Politics of Race and Indigeneity in the Arctic" (Duke UP, 2025)

·1 hr 1 min·5 clips
Alaska Native peoples were legally categorized as Asian to block land claims until the mid-1900s.
The guest discusses the book as a book about how ice geographies are imagined and governed. The interview opens with the book's focus on climate determinism and environmental determinism. From there, it moves into the long habit of treating ice geographies as empty, sterile, or barren. The guest makes clear that those descriptions are not neutral. They help organize power. They also shape what kinds of people and futures are treated as fitting for a place. The host raises climate determinism as one way to frame that history. The conversation then expands to environmental determinism and the more specific idea of temperate normativity. The guest says they wanted a concept that could travel. They use it to show that some spaces are upheld as if they should produce a certain perfect body and mind. That framework is not only about harm done to racialized people. It is also about the hierarchy created between different kinds of space. The discussion keeps coming back to the fact that space is not just described. It is valued, ranked, and used to justify different forms of attention and neglect. The host asks how the book sits beside scholarship on other geographies read in similar ways. Deserts come up as one example. The Amazon comes up as another. So does the broader tendency to devalue some places while overinvesting them with conservation meaning. The guest says they read widely across historical and philosophical work while writing the book. They note that many scholars have already traced these patterns in hot or desert contexts. Their point is that Arctic spaces can be part of the same analytic conversation. The exchange closes by stressing how useful it is to build complexity from multiple archives and materials. The tone stays appreciative and measured throughout. It feels like a scholarly conversation aimed at helping listeners understand why these ideas matter beyond one region.

As heard by us

A careful discussion of how ice geographies are read, racialized, and folded into a hierarchy of space.

The episode treats ice geographies as more than backdrop, and it keeps its attention on climate, environmental determinism, and temperate normativity without losing the thread.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the Arctic treated as a political geography, not a scenic blank.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on