New Books in Biology and Evolution · New Books Network

Steven Lesk, "Footprints of Schizophrenia: The Evolutionary Roots of Mental Illness" (Prometheus, 2023)

·1 hr 2 min·5 clips

Stephen Lesk claims mental illness is an evolutionary glitch that will vanish in 20,000 years.

This episode features psychiatrist Dr. Stephen Lesk discussing his book on the evolutionary origins of mental illness with host Ari Barbalat. Dr. Lesk draws on nearly four decades of clinical experience to critique mainstream psychiatric explanations. He argues that all mental illnesses, including schizophrenia and depression, stem from a recent evolutionary "glitch" tied to the development of human language. Lesk proposes his "primitive organizational theory," stating that mental illness results from an inability to fully adapt to the cognitive demands of language, which emerged only 50,000 years ago. He claims disorders like schizophrenia represent a regression to a more primitive, childlike state of thinking due to a "de-suppression" or surge of dopamine. The psychiatrist connects diverse conditions—Alzheimer's, Parkinson's, Tourette's, OCD, and bipolar disorder—to imbalances between dopamine and its "sister chemical," acetylcholine. He references the case of Judge Paul Schreber, whose memoirs influenced Freud's theory of paranoia, as a key example of detailed psychotic experience. A surprising claim is that mental illness did not exist 50,000 years ago and will not exist 20,000 years from once this evolutionary transition is complete. Lesk asserts that genetics are merely a risk factor, not a cause, citing the less-than-50% concordance rate in identical twins for schizophrenia. He suggests obsessive-compulsive thinking was a foundational element in building ordered civilization. The interview includes a memorable anecdote where a patient with schizophrenia, asked why the sun rises, answered "tomorrow," citing the musical *Annie*, which Lesk uses to illustrate regressive, concrete thinking. Lesk is highly critical of contemporary psychiatry, which he describes as being "in the dark ages" for lacking biological tests and ignoring evolutionary theory. He states the field's reliance on patient self-reporting and the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM) as an "insurance manual" are significant limitations. The tone is conversational yet didactic, featuring a passionate and sometimes frustrated expert advocating for a paradigm shift. Lesk's style is declarative and sweeping, presenting his theory as a unifying framework for all mental pathology. Listeners interested in bold, evolutionary perspectives on psychology and critiques of biological psychiatry will find this episode compelling. Those seeking nuanced, evidence-based debate or who are uncomfortable with broad, speculative theories might choose to skip it.

As heard by us

A wide-ranging psychiatry conversation about language, evolution, and the mental costs of becoming symbolic animals.

Dr. Stephen Lusk's Footprints of Schizophrenia makes a broad case that mental illness belongs in an evolutionary story, starting with language and the link between symbols, reality testing, and brain chemistry.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want psychiatry braided with language, symbol-making, and the evolution of mental illness, press play.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from New Books in Biology and Evolution