New Books in Australian and New Zealand Studies · Marshall Poe

Matthew Scobie and Anna Sturman, "The Economic Possibilities of Decolonisation" (Bridget Williams Books, 2024)

·56 min·3 clips
1840 preemption, raupatu, and the Native Land Court turn land into the core colonial weapon.
1. New Books in Australian and New Zealand Studies speaks with Dr. Miranda Melcher, Matthew Scobie, and Anna Sturman about Bridget Williams Books' 2024 title The Economic Possibilities of Decolonisation. 2. Melcher hosts the episode, Scobie teaches and researches at the University of Canterbury, and Sturman is a political economist and human geographer at the University of Sydney. 3. The conversation asks what Māori political economy can explain about colonial capitalism in Aotearoa New Zealand and what future change might require. 4. Scobie traces the book to a lockdown call from Ngāi Tahu leader Te Māori Tau, who asked for "two pages" on how the Crown uses crises to extend power at Māori expense. 5. Sturman says her PhD on agriculture and climate change in Aotearoa already examined productive development, social costs, and Māori labour. 6. Scobie describes pre-colonial economies through taonga, whakapapa, and exchange networks that moved pounamu from specific South Island sources across the country. 7. He contrasts those arrangements with wage labour and individual fee simple title, arguing that Māori property and labour were organized through obligations rather than markets. 8. Sturman says the first European arrivals did not immediately create systematic colonization, because Māori and iwi still set many of the terms of exchange. 9. The interview turns to the Treaty of Waitangi, where 1840 preemption made the Crown the single buyer of Māori land and later raupatu, invasion, and confiscation deepened dispossession. 10. Scobie adds that the Native Land Court individualized title and imposed survey and legal fees that pushed owners toward sale. 11. He also notes the South Island's kumara line near Te Waihora as one reason agricultural economies differed sharply across Aotearoa. 12. The book frames tangata whenua through whenua, burial, and whakapapa, then argues that land severance leaves property relations in place of a living land-based relationship. 13. Sturman says the Māori economy still appears in marae practice, where large gatherings must feed people, honour guests, and farewell the dead. 14. Scobie points to mahinga kai as a living Ngāi Tahu practice that survived wetlands drainage, river damming, and fencing. 15. Both authors treat post-settlement governance entities such as Te Rūnanga o Ngāi Tahu as mixed instruments that fund scholarships, language revival, legal teams, and new contradictions. 16. Sturman argues that crisis moments like COVID-19, black summer bushfires, floods, and Christchurch earthquakes reveal forms of care and social reproduction that capitalist institutions often miss. 17. The interview is careful, explanatory, and caveat-heavy, with Scobie repeatedly flagging source limits, regional variation, and the danger of flattening Māori history into one story. 18. Melcher keeps the conversation structured with direct follow-up questions about pre-colonial life, land loss, present institutions, and future implications. 19. Listeners interested in Māori studies, decolonisation, political economy, and Treaty politics in Aotearoa New Zealand will get the most from it. 20. Listeners wanting a light cultural chat without colonial history or policy detail will probably skip it.

As heard by us

A thoughtful discussion of land, exchange, and Maori political economy as foundations for decolonisation.

Dr. Matthew Scobie and Dr. Anna Sturman discuss how Maori communities might approach markets not simply as outside pressures, but as spaces where existing relationships of exchange can be carried forward.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want a thoughtful guide to how land, markets, and Maori political economy shape the economic possibilities of decolonization?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on