New Books in Australian and New Zealand Studies · Marshall Poe

Karen Patel, "Craft as a Creative Industry" (Routledge, 2024)

·50 min·3 clips
Patel's two-part framework says craft value should be judged by object expertise and community-led evaluation.
1. New Books in Critical Theory speaks with Karen Patel about "Craft as a Creative Industry," a Routledge short-form book on hand-made making and cultural policy. 2. Dave hosts the interview, and Karen Patel says the project grew from Crafts Council research funded by the Arts and Humanities Research Council. 3. The episode asks why craft counts as a creative industry at all, and Patel argues that policy and labour shape who gets recognition and who can make a living. 4. Patel uses the Crafts Council definition of craft as objects and artefacts made by hand using materials, including jewellery, woodwork, textiles, knitting, sewing, and ceramics. 5. She says the UK government proposed removing craft from the creative-industries categories in 2013, and the Crafts Council lobbied to keep the category in place. 6. Patel notes that freelancing, sole trading, part-time work, and hobbyist making all blur the line between professional and amateur craft labour. 7. Her UK history reaches back to medieval craft guilds, which were open to men and their sons and excluded women except through marriage. 8. She links those guild structures to present-day craft organisations, where restricted entry conditions and narrow ideas of quality still shape access. 9. Patel also tracks the Arts and Crafts movement, William Morris, and May Morris, showing how the movement elevated craft while preserving exclusionary club-like structures. 10. She highlights women at the Birmingham School of Art, where May Morris set up embroidery groups and led courses for young women. 11. The Commonwealth Institute becomes another key reference point, because Patel cites Ruth Craggs's criticism that it exoticised and museumised colonial cultures in a whitewashed version of British history. 12. In Australia, Patel uses Papunya Tula, about 200 kilometres north of Alice Springs, to show how First Nations art and craft reached prominence through a story that often centres Geoffrey Barden. 13. She pushes back on that origin story by pointing to earlier woodcarvers and painters such as Albert Namatidra and Clifford Possum, whose work appeared in the 1930s and 1940s. 14. Patel also names First Nations women makers such as Yvonne Coulmantry and Thamkoopy, who gained wider recognition later, especially through historians and curators such as Hetty Perkins. 15. Her UK interviews with makers describe repeated microaggressions, including one studio holder saying "we don't have brown people here" and another maker being mistaken for a different Black woman. 16. Several interviewees describe contradictory expectations, including being told their work is too close to their heritage to sell and also that it should be more British. 17. Patel contrasts the UK with Australian socially engaged organisations such as the Jam Factory in Adelaide and the Social Studio in Melbourne, which benefit from government support, university links, and on-site shops. 18. She closes with a two-part framework that draws on Georgina Bourne and Janet Wolfe to combine object-based judgments of craft expertise with more democratic, community-led evaluation. 19. Listeners who care about craft, arts policy, cultural studies, or creative-sector equity will get the most from the discussion. 20. Listeners looking for a light promotional chat about making may find the policy detail, inequality analysis, and colonial history too dense.

As heard by us

A clear, grounded look at Australian craft, First Nations making, and the systems shaping cultural visibility.

The episode traces Australian craft through the force of British colonialism, with attention to its effects on First Nations people, communities, and ways of life.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want Australian craft history with the colonial context left in, and with First Nations art and craft visibility treated as a live tension.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on