Mystery is My Hobby Presented by the Great Detectives of Old Time Radio · Adam Graham Radio Detective Podcasts

Mystery is My Hobby: Death of an Old Prospector

·31 min·2 clips

The Inspector learns the boots carried rattlesnake fangs, and Matt dies after stealing them.

1. Mystery is My Hobby: Death of an Old Prospector follows Barton Drake and Inspector Danton on horseback across the Arizona desert near the Welcome U Ranch. 2. Barton Drake is the amateur detective, Inspector Danton is the police inspector, and Shirley Wiggins, Hardtack Wiggins, Matt Palmer, and Oliver Runyon drive the dispute. 3. The episode asks how an old prospector died, why he carried gold, and who benefits from his death. 4. Barton and Danton find Hardtack Wiggins lying near a giant cactus, and the Inspector first guesses heart failure while Barton checks for signs of violence. 5. The body has a pair of brand-new boots, patched jeans, a faded shirt, and brown stains on the beard that Barton calls tobacco stains. 6. Shirley Wiggins arrives on horseback and identifies the dead man as her husband, Hardtack Wiggins. 7. Shirley says she married Hardtack at the Coyote Wells city hall that morning, only two days after meeting him. 8. She says Hardtack found a pocket of gold two weeks earlier and that assayers valued it at half a million dollars. 9. Matt Palmer and Oliver Runyon then arrive and each argues that he has a claim to the gold through Hardtack’s partnership and inheritance. 10. Barton notes that the men’s arguments make the death look like a fight over money rather than a simple accident. 11. Shirley warns that Hardtack could not have died of heart failure because Doc Sandbar and Coyote Wells examined him the day before and found him in perfect health. 12. Barton and the Inspector later uncover a knife wound that had no blood, which points them away from a fresh stabbing. 13. The trail back from the body shows staggering footprints, an empty whiskey bottle, and a dead rattlesnake. 14. Bart explains that whiskey is not an antidote for snakebite, so the bottle becomes part of the death sequence rather than a cure. 15. The Inspector shoots the dead rattler’s head off and then learns he has mistaken a corpse for live prey. 16. Barton concludes that Hardtack likely stepped on the snake first, tore open his shirt in pain, and then collapsed on the trail. 17. Barton says Matt Palmer later stabbed the already-dead Hardtack and tried to make the scene look like snakebite. 18. The episode ends with Barton explaining how Hardtack’s boot leather held the rattlesnake fangs and how Matt’s theft of the boots sealed his fate. 19. The tone is fast, bantering, and procedural, with Barton correcting the Inspector while the two of them keep moving through the desert. 20. Listeners who like classic radio mysteries with desert clues and sarcastic dialogue will enjoy it, while listeners wanting a modern, slow-burn crime drama may skip it.

As heard by us

A death over gold turns into brisk, unsentimental inheritance drama.

When Hardtack dies, the episode turns into a row over gold, inheritance, and who thinks they deserve the money. It is less a slow puzzle than a loud scramble, with everyone pushing their angle and every answer landing with more temper than the last.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a murder mystery where a gold strike turns the room into a knife fight.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Mystery is My Hobby Presented by the Great Detectives of Old Time Radio