Mystery is My Hobby Presented by the Great Detectives of Old Time Radio · Adam Graham Radio Detective Podcasts

Mystery is My Hobby: Death is Twin

·34 min·2 clips

Barton Drake says George Gale moved the body, forged the suicide scene, and used Susan’s identity.

The episode opens inside a murder scene that already feels half explained and half wrong. A body sits slumped in a chair. A book lies in her lap. A glass of milk is on the floor, and the spot was analyzed and found to contain poison. The broken window is treated as the apparent point of entry. The detective questions how the door was opened. The inspector says a key was used from the inside. That detail makes the room feel less straightforward than it first seemed. The victim is identified as Claire Waterstone. The detective and inspector head to the morgue to look at her body. The morgue attendant greets them with the same deadpan routine the show leans on everywhere else. The inspector complains that he is hungry. The attendant turns that into a joke about cadavers and starvation, the kind of customer service only this sort of story can get away with. When Claire is brought out, the attendant notices how sad she looks. The detective sees a remarkable resemblance to George. The answer lands plainly: they were identical twins. The case shifts from a poison death to a puzzle about mistaken identity and mirrored lives. The scene is built almost entirely through dialogue. Questions come fast. Answers come with impatience. The clues are practical rather than decorative. The show keeps the pace moving by letting the detective and inspector push against each other instead of stopping to explain everything. Even the morgue scene stays brisk and sardonic. The mystery stays grounded in physical evidence. The milk matters. The window matters. The book matters. The twin resemblance matters most of all. The episode prefers short beats over long reflection. It keeps the mystery compact and the room slightly unruly. The result is a classic old time radio detective shape with a small but effective identity twist.

As heard by us

A brisk twin-switch mystery with poison, banter, and a clean old-radio snap.

A poisoned glass of milk, a dead woman in a chair, and an identical twin set the stage fast. What gives it bite is the clipped back-and-forth, where the clues come out in argument and the dry little jabs keep it from getting solemn.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a tight old-time-radio murder case with an identical-twin wrinkle.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Mystery is My Hobby Presented by the Great Detectives of Old Time Radio