Mystery and Murder: Analysis by Dr. Phil · Dr. Phil McGraw

The Disappearance of Stacy Ann Peterson

·53 min·3 clips

“The worst thing in the world is a narcissist with a badge and a gun.”

1. Mystery and Murder: Analysis by Dr. Phil focuses on the disappearance of Stacey Ann Peterson from Bolingbrook, Illinois, on October 28, 2007. 2. Dr. Phil is the host and narrator, and his analysis drives the episode by comparing Drew Peterson's conduct with baseline behavior. 3. The episode asks whether Stacey's disappearance was voluntary or part of a larger pattern involving Drew Peterson and Kathleen Savio. 4. Stacey was 23, the mother of two, and married to Drew Peterson, a local police officer with public credibility in Bolingbrook. 5. Drew said Stacey left around 10 in the morning wearing a blue jacket, and he later claimed he found her car at a nearby airport and drove it home. 6. Dr. Phil emphasizes that Drew did not call Stacey's mother, father, or the police right away, and he reported her missing about 24 hours later. 7. The episode notes there was no note, no signs of a struggle, no confirmed sightings, no luggage gone, and no bank accounts touched. 8. Friends and family immediately rejected the idea that Stacey had simply run away, because she had two babies at home and had begun fearing Drew. 9. Stacey had told people she was considering divorce, had recorded conversations, and had hidden documents. 10. Her sister recalled Stacey saying, "if anything ever happens to me, Drew did something." 11. Dr. Phil then turns to Kathleen Savio, Drew's third wife, as the earlier case that shaped the way investigators later viewed Stacey's disappearance. 12. Kathleen filed for divorce in October 2001 and accused Drew of abuse, including an allegation that he was having an affair with Stacey when Stacey was still a minor. 13. Kathleen also obtained a temporary order of protection against Drew after saying she feared he might try to kill her. 14. The episode describes Drew and Kathleen's marriage as hostile, with police called to their home repeatedly for domestic disturbances. 15. Between 2002 and 2004, police were called to the Peterson home 18 times, and those responses became routine to neighbors and officers. 16. Friends said Kathleen described physical aggression, threats, and fear, including the claim that she slept with a knife under her mattress. 17. Dr. Phil argues that law enforcement became desensitized and that the "badge" mattered because Drew was a police sergeant who knew the officers and the system. 18. The episode says Kathleen was found dead on March 1, 2004, in an empty bathtub, initially ruled an accidental drowning, and later reexamined after Stacey disappeared. 19. A second autopsy found injuries, fluid in the lungs, and cerebral edema that supported a homicide classification, and investigators later charged Drew with Kathleen Savio's murder. 20. The episode's tone is accusatory and analytical, with repeated rhetorical questions, and it will appeal most to true-crime listeners interested in police-power dynamics or skip by listeners wanting a neutral procedural summary.

As heard by us

A missing-wife case where Drew Peterson's calm says more than his story.

Stacey Ann Peterson's disappearance is framed as a domestic case, but the unsettling part is Drew Peterson's easy refusal to treat the alarm as serious.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

For when you want the suspect's calmness treated as evidence, not atmosphere.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Mystery and Murder: Analysis by Dr. Phil