Mystery and Murder: Analysis by Dr. Phil · Dr. Phil McGraw

S19EP1: Inside The Gilgo Beach Murders | Mystery and Murder: Analysis by Dr. Phil

·43 min·1 clip

Bodies discarded at civilization's edge, their names carried away by ocean winds—and society forgot them.

This episode of *Mystery and Murder: Analysis by Dr. Phil* dissects the infamous Gilgo Beach serial killings, a case involving at least 11 victims discovered along Long Island's shoreline. Host Dr. Phil McGraw applies his psychological expertise to analyze the perpetrator's mind and the investigation's failures. The episode focuses on the initial disappearance of Shannon Gilbert and the subsequent discovery of multiple murder victims. Shannon Gilbert, a 23-year-old escort, made a frantic 22-minute 911 call from Oak Beach on May 1, 2010, claiming someone was trying to kill her before vanishing. The 911 call featured the voices of her client, Joseph Brewer, and her driver, Michael Pack, with Shannon at one point asking Pack, "are you going to kill me?" Despite neighbors Gus Coletti and Barbara Brennan also calling 911 about a distressed woman, police did not connect Shannon's disappearance to the earlier emergency call for about a month. The search for Shannon in late 2010 instead led to the discovery of four other women wrapped in burlap, known as the Gilgo Four: Melissa Barthelemy, Maureen Brainerd-Barnes, Megan Waterman, and Amber Lynn Costello, all believed to be strangled. Melissa Barthelemy's 15-year-old sister, Amanda, received terrifying phone calls from an anonymous man after Melissa's disappearance. Further searches in 2011 revealed more victims, including Jessica Taylor, Valerie Mack, an unidentified woman called "Peaches," a toddler ("Baby Doe"), Karen Vergata, and an unidentified Asian male wearing women's clothing. A chilling insight is that the killer likely targeted sex workers, a group for whom a *Journal of Forensic Sciences* study found 94% of female homicide victims, counting on systemic indifference. Criminal profilers described the unknown killer as a white male, 25-45, methodical, forensic-aware, and likely maintaining a normal outward life, a "modern-day Jekyll and Hyde." Dr. Phil emphasizes the calculated evil of someone who could calmly schedule a victim online knowing they intended to murder them. The investigation was hampered for years by corruption, notably from Suffolk County Police Chief James Burke, who was later imprisoned for assault and obstruction. A major break came over a decade later with the emergence of a suspect, Rex Heuermann, though the episode ends before detailing his arrest or alleged connection to Shannon Gilbert's still-unsolved disappearance. The tone is dramatic and educational, blending narrative storytelling with psychological analysis and stark societal criticism. Dr. Phil's delivery is direct and often indignant, particularly when discussing investigative failures and the victimization of marginalized women. True crime enthusiasts fascinated by deep dives into infamous serial killer cases and forensic psychology will find this episode gripping. Listeners seeking resolution or a straightforward recounting of facts may be frustrated by the cliffhanger ending and the host's emphatic editorializing.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Mystery and Murder: Analysis by Dr. Phil