Mutiny Investing Podcast · Jason Buck

57. Sequencing Risk: Why The Expected Value Is Not What You Should Expect | Cockroach Strategy (Part 2)

·20 min·1 clip
Jason concludes that sequence risk alone can mean a $36,500 or a $134,000 annual retirement income from the same savings.
Part two keeps the Cockroach Series moving. The conversation shifts from broad market averages to sequencing risk, ergodicity, retirement planning, and the drawdown problem that can hit at exactly the wrong moment. The hosts keep the example simple. Nick and Nancy are 63, have $3 million saved, want to spend $180,000 a year, and expect spending to rise 3% annually, so the usual average-return story looks fine until the order of returns is spelled out. That is where the math starts to matter. A period that averages 8% can still contain a first half that is close to zero and a second half that is much stronger, and the same return stream leads to a very different outcome depending on when retirement begins. One path is rough. If they retire into the weak stretch first, withdrawals keep coming and the account runs out in about 12 years. The other path is almost insulting. If they retire into the stronger stretch first, the account grows while they are still taking money out, gets to more than $12 million after roughly 15 years, and still leaves them with more than $6 million by age 95. The show keeps circling the same point. Expected value can be technically correct and still be the wrong thing to lean on when sequence of returns decides whether a retiree makes it through the trip. That is the practical lesson here. The conversation treats retirement less like a neat formula and more like a live cash flow problem, where the timing of bad years matters as much as the return level itself. It also keeps the tone grounded. Instead of dressing the idea up as a grand theory, the hosts keep translating it into the things a person actually feels: whether the portfolio compounds, whether withdrawals become a drag, and what that means across a 95-year lifespan. The jargon does not stay abstract for long. Sequence risk, ergodicity, and return streams get pulled back toward ordinary portfolio choices and the uncomfortable fact that two investors can face the same market and still end up in different places. The example lands as a reminder that planning assumptions are fragile. Averages can look tidy, but retirement gets lived in sequence, not in summary statistics. By the end, the argument is clear. Averages are useful, but retirement decisions live or die on the order in which those averages show up.

As heard by us

A clear look at sequencing risk and how the same returns can lead to very different retirement outcomes.

Part two of the Cockroach Series stays on sequencing risk, retirement planning, ergodicity, and how the order of returns can change an ending.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You care more about retirement drawdowns than tidy average-return stories.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on