Murders and Mysteries of New England · Marti Shaw

The Murder of Joseph Zarelli

·20 min·1 clip
The boy had suffered extensive physical abuse prior to his death and was severely malnourished and covered in scars.
The host details the 1957 cold case of Joseph Augustus Zarelli, the 'boy in the box,' whose beaten body was found in Philadelphia. The episode covers the discovery, the decades-long investigation, four major theories about his death, and how modern DNA genealogy finally identified him in 2022, though his murder remains unsolved.

As heard by us

A measured return to the Boy in the Box case that keeps the uncertainty intact.

Marty Shaw's episode of Murders and Mysteries of New England returns to the Boy in the Box case in Philadelphia with unusual care. It does its best work when it lays out the known facts first, then gives the foster-home theory and M's later claim enough room to breathe.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a careful walk through the Boy in the Box case in Philadelphia, centered on Joseph Augustus Zarelli and the unresolved question of what happened to him.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on