Murders and Mysteries of New England · Marti Shaw

The Murder of Holly Piirainen

·55 min

Mardi Shaw starts with a welcome. Before she gets into Holly's story, she thanks listeners for their patience, explains that a lot has kept her away from podcasting, and admits the show is still trying to find its rhythm. Then the case takes over. Her voice shifts into a grave, personal walkthrough. She wants to stay factual, but she is clearly reacting like a person, too. Holly was ten years old. That fact sits in the middle of the excerpt because Shaw keeps coming back to how unbearable it is for a child to face something so traumatic. She almost follows that thought further, then pulls herself back. Instead of staying in the grief, she returns to the evidence investigators have discussed. The shirt matters. Shaw describes a white tank top with Boston on the front in blue, purple, and pink. It looks dirty on both sides, though she is careful not to guess whether the dirt was intentional or accidental. There do not seem to be manufacturing tags or size details, but investigators believe it may be some kind of adult size. They still want to know where the shirt came from and who it may have belonged to. Shaw points listeners to Instagram because seeing it is clearer than hearing her describe it. That mention feels practical, not promotional. The transcript keeps its rough edges: restarts, small corrections, and moments where Shaw says she wants to begin a line again. The rawness fits the case file feel. By the end, she connects Holly's case to her research on Molly Bish and explains why she waited before covering it. The closing is plain. Holly's case matters as much as anyone else's.

As heard by us

A careful case discussion that keeps the evidence and the grief close.

This episode returns to Holly Piirainen's case, with Mardi Shaw opening by thanking listeners after some time away. It lingers on the evidence investigators are still trying to trace, including a white Boston tank top, and keeps the focus on what happened to a 10-year-old child.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play if you want a careful New England true-crime case walkthrough built around the Holly Piranin case and the evidence investigators discuss.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify