Nancy Guthrie: “Gone in the Night” | MURDERISH Ep. 207

·41 min·4 clips

A masked commando disables Nancy Guthrie's security system and abducts her from her bed at 2:28 a.m.

The episode opens with a detailed narrative of Nancy Guthrie's abduction from her Catalina Foothills home in Tucson on February 1, 2026, after her security system was disabled. It establishes Nancy as the mother of NBC's Savannah Guthrie and a longtime Tucson resident. The investigation begins when Nancy misses a church livestream, and her daughter Annie finds signs of a struggle. The Pima County Sheriff's Office and FBI respond, finding drops of blood and evidence of forced entry. The kidnapper used a Wi-Fi jammer, causing a neighborhood blackout. Former FBI agent Tracy Chandler-Walder notes the property's layout made it vulnerable. The case gains national attention. On February 2, encrypted ransom demands for $4-6 million in Bitcoin are sent to TMZ, containing intimate details about the home. Savannah Guthrie takes leave from NBC and makes public appeals, offering a $1 million reward. Forensic evidence includes a DNA sample not belonging to Nancy's circle and black fibers from an Ozark Trail backpack sold at Walmart. The FBI recovers a 15-second Nest camera video showing a masked figure in tactical gear at Nancy's door. A neighbor's camera captures a similar person earlier. False alarms occur, including a SWAT response that detains but releases individuals. A man, Derek Colella, is arrested for attempting to scam the family. The investigation expands to Mexico, with border checks and a helicopter searching for Nancy's pacemaker signal. Investigative genetic genealogy is considered for the DNA sample. The episode notes the rarity of elderly kidnappings and the overwhelming volume of public tips. Retired detectives comment on the case's unusual nature and challenges. Savannah Guthrie posts a faith-based message. The episode concludes with the case still unsolved after two months.

As heard by us

A missing-person case turns sharply when encrypted ransom messages suggest intimate knowledge of the house.

Nancy Guthrie's disappearance shifts from a terrifying missing-person case into a ransom investigation shaped by a $4 million Bitcoin demand and messages routed to news outlets instead of her family.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

When Nancy Guthrie's disappearance hits national broadcasts, your next listen turns on an anonymous message and a $4 million Bitcoin demand.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from MURDERISH