Murder Shelf Book Club Podcast · murdershelfbookclub

Special Episode 140: Expert Witness Dr Ann Burgess speaks!

·51 min·4 clips

Dr. Burgess dissects the Menendez case, exposing how bias against male victims shaped the verdict.

Host Jill interviews Dr. Ann Wolbert Burgess, a pioneering forensic psychiatric nurse and former FBI consultant, about her new book "Expert Witness." Dr. Burgess reflects on her decades of work providing expert testimony in high-profile criminal cases. She details her involvement in the trials of the Menendez brothers, Bill Cosby, and Larry Nassar, explaining her role in analyzing victim trauma and offender patterns. Dr. Burgess discusses the Duke Lacrosse case, where the accuser later admitted to lying, and the concept of confabulation in memory. She describes testifying for both prosecution and defense, including in death penalty cases like that of serial killer Henry Wallace. A key insight is her analysis of the systemic disbelief toward male sexual abuse victims during the Menendez brothers' trials over 35 years ago. Dr. Burgess explains how trauma causes delayed disclosure and why victims often cannot immediately report assaults. She identifies institutional betrayal, as seen in the Nassar case, where organizations cover up abuse. The conversation covers her recent research on violence within Indigenous communities, noting patterns like familial perpetrators in elder murders and the prominence of sadistic motives. Dr. Burgess advocates for using AI in criminal profiling, recalling the FBI's initial dismissal of the idea decades ago as "Star Wars stuff." She shares a recent courtroom victory where a woman in her 60s won a lawsuit for a childhood sexual assault, demonstrating lasting trauma impacts. The tone is conversational and educational, blending personal anecdotes with professional analysis of forensic psychology and legal processes. Listeners interested in forensic science, criminal justice reform, and victim advocacy will find this episode compelling. Those seeking light entertainment or purely narrative true crime stories might find the detailed procedural discussion less engaging.

As heard by us

A respectful, evidence-first conversation with Dr. Ann Wolbert Burgess.

This episode centers Dr. Ann Wolbert Burgess and the reach of her work in difficult cases tied to the Menendez brothers, Bill Cosby, and Larry Nassar.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Listen if you want Dr. Ann Wolbert Burgess on trauma, testimony, and the cases that shaped her work.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Murder Shelf Book Club Podcast