Murder Mistery

Roena and Connie: Rivals' Feud Fuels Fatal End

·44 min·4 clips
John McIntyre describes strangling Tom Bauer with his own belt and setting his body on fire.
It begins with a fire. At 2:15 a.m. on August 10, 1992, crews respond to a fast-moving house fire in the northwest section of town, where civilians are shouting that a wheelchair-bound man is still inside. Tom Bauer dies there. Investigators conclude the fire was a homicide and bring cab driver Rowena Ashing in for questioning after her name surfaces in the case. Rowena says her fingerprints would be expected because she drove him. The narrative then breaks the attack down step by step. A group goes to Bauer's house with gas, a frying skillet, and a plan to find money. They crawl in through the back window, search the house, strike him in the head, take off his belt, strangle him, and then douse and burn the place. John McIntyre's confession backs up parts of that sequence. Richie Loftus, who acted as the driver, also supports elements of the account. Even so, the episode keeps the legal standard in view and does not present those statements as complete proof against Rowena. Rowena later asks to speak with police again before being sent to county jail on theft charges. She says she wants to get it off her chest and insists she was only connected to the people around the crime. She links the trouble to boyfriend Jeff Ramsey after Bauer accused her of theft. The episode then turns to Connie Keel. Connie says she was arrested on the highway after a liquor-store robbery that ended in the murder of clerk Frank Gummer, and the evidence described in her case places her as a lookout rather than a ride-along. The closing material follows her after 27 years in prison, as she speaks about therapy, family pain, and the life she wants if parole comes. Her wish is plain: to go home, see her children and grandchildren, and give back.

As heard by us

Two brutal cases, told with procedural clarity and a restrained hand.

Rowena Ashing and Connie Keel sit at the center of two hard, ugly cases. One is tied to a burned house and the police work around Tom Bauer's death. The other follows Connie Keel's account of a liquor store robbery and murder, along with the case built against her as the lookout.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You get a wheelchair-bound victim, a robbery-murder, and two women whose accounts keep tightening the net.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on