Murder Mistery

Murder in Paradise: Bliss Betrays a Bloody Secret

·44 min·4 clips
Three women on death row confess to brutal crimes, from murder to cannibalism, in their own chilling words.
Three women anchor the episode through their own prison statements. Their words come first, and only then do the cases start to take shape. One voice turns to attempted murder and assault with a deadly weapon. Another recalls violence, drugs, and a life that narrowed until prison was the last stop. The first major case is set in Aurora, Colorado, on a cloudy Saturday afternoon in the summer of 2003. The story marks the time carefully, down to 4:03 PM and the storm building over the city. From there, the episode shifts to Hawaii. It describes a drug culture where meth, called ice, sits at the center of daily life. Melissa Ordonez describes early use of crystal meth, marijuana, cigarettes, and alcohol. She says addiction made the fast life feel powerful. Federal agents later moved on a Maui drug ring in September 2004. They seized two pounds of meth and $250,000 in cash. Thirteen people were arrested, including Melissa. She says she was caught talking about drugs with one man from the ring. Authorities charged her with conspiracy to possess and to distribute ice. She received three years' probation and one day time served, which the narration frames as an enormous break. The episode then follows her attempt to start over. She says she left Maui, moved to Oahu, and enrolled at the University of Hawaii. It also brings in Jericho Lindsey, a boyfriend she kept seeing, and Benjamin Grijeda, a man she met after clubbing. Melissa says Jericho gave her expensive gifts and had a cold streak. Police claim Benjamin's electronics-store story was a cover. The episode keeps building through those contradictions, using testimony, suspicion, and shifting relationships to show how a case can move from romance and recovery into something far more dangerous. It keeps circling confession, consequence, and the lives already damaged.

As heard by us

Prison confessions and violent casework are handled with steady, grave control.

This episode centers on prison confessions and violent turning points, moving from an attempted murder case in Aurora in 2003 to drug-fueled crimes in Hawaii and other hard admissions that carry real weight.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want confessions that stay tied to charges, sentences, and consequences, press play.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on