Forgotten Shadows: Cases Cry Out for Resolution

·46 min·4 clips

Stephen Michalak tried English, Russian, Polish, and German to communicate with a mysterious craft that landed near him.

This episode of "Murder Mystery" presents three unsolved cases from the "Unsolved Mysteries" series, narrated in a documentary style. The stories involve a UFO encounter, a prison death cover-up, and a small-town disappearance. Stephen Michalak, a Polish immigrant in Manitoba, claims a disc-shaped craft burned a grid pattern onto his chest in 1967. In California, former prison guard Betty Thompson alleges a conspiracy behind inmate Terry Lucas's death, linking it to the 1984 disappearance of guard Jessalyn Rich. In Houma, Louisiana, reliable family man A.J. Breaux vanished in 1991, with witnesses later reporting sightings of him with three men in a red car. Michalak's doctors could not diagnose his burns or his symptoms, which included nausea and a sulfurous odor, though radiation tests were negative. Investigators found a radioactive, pure silver substance at his encounter site, which skeptic Ed Barker believes was planted. At Frontera Prison, Terry Lucas told Thompson she had evidence about Rich's fate before being found dead with grass in her hair and signs of assault. Thompson says a coroner initially called it murder but changed his ruling after meeting with prison officials. Jessalyn Rich vanished after seeming frightened at a bar, and her brother found a torn-up note in her trash referencing a drug-related threat. Thompson claims she was forced under threat to sign a false report on Lucas's death and later received a threatening phone call saying "next time we won't miss." For A.J. Breaux, a mysterious note claimed he died in a drunken accident, but dredging the bayou found nothing, and witness Christy Boudreau later reported a man matching his mugshot trying to sell fish. A surprising detail is the perfectly patterned burns on Michalak's abdomen matching the craft's grid, which left permanent subcutaneous scar tissue he calls his "buttons." The discovery of manufactured, radioactive silver bars at the UFO site remains a major unexplained puzzle. The prison story's most chilling moment is an administrator allegedly telling Thompson "the same thing that happened to Jessalyn Rich could easily happen to me." The episode also includes a heartwarming update where Kathy Loving reunites with former deputy Fred Lyle, who believed her story of abuse and helped free her from a reform school 30 years prior. The tone is serious, investigative, and suspenseful, blending firsthand witness accounts with dramatic reenactments. The style is classic true-crime documentary, aiming to present puzzling evidence without definitive conclusions. This episode will appeal to fans of unsolved phenomena, detailed cold cases, and institutional corruption stories. Listeners seeking resolved narratives or who are uncomfortable with allegations of official cover-ups might choose to skip it.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Murder Mistery