Murder Mistery

Dolly Mae and Shaniqua: Streets Surge with Savage Acts

·44 min·4 clips
Dolly Mae Clapp describes how Harold Bonner poured liquid heat in Michelle Hicks' mouth and inserted ammonia in her nose during the torture killing.
The episode follows two brutal cases tied to women pulled into murder investigations. In Buffalo, police find Michelle Hicks in a vacant lot on the east side on January 6, 2006, and the case points to a torture killing involving beating, gagging, binding, chemicals, and strangulation. The trail goes cold, then starts to tighten again. Investigators identify Harold Bonner as a pimp who controlled his woman through fear, and they also focus on Dolly Mae Clapp, a 47-year-old woman described as his second in command. Two informants help move the case forward. One is a man from jail who helped Bonner and Clapp dispose of Hicks's body, and his account leads detectives to bring Dolly in for questioning. Dolly starts by denying involvement. She says she only heard the murder over the phone, but detectives think she knows more than she is saying and press until the story starts to shift. Once she talks, she gives a detailed account of the killing, down to the bags, the rope, the panties, and the ammonia used in the assault. The episode treats that confession as a turning point, not a clean win. Dolly later claims she made up parts of the statement, which leaves the listener with a version of events still shaped by pressure, fear, and damage. The second case moves into a robbery that ends in murder. Shaniqua Brown describes being involved in a plan to rob a Chinese food delivery man, and her account lands on the blood, the footprints, and the shock of seeing the victim afterward. The math is small. The victim is said to carry only change for twenty dollars, which turns the robbery into a blunt question about greed, risk, and the value assigned to a life. The episode keeps circling back to consequence. It ends with remorse and responsibility, as the women describe what cannot be undone and how the damage reaches beyond them to families and the wider community. The final note is not exoneration. It is the burden of living with what happened long after the police interviews are over.

As heard by us

A grim two case episode that builds its tension through confession, procedure, and the human cost of violence.

This episode follows two women tied to separate crimes: the murder of Michelle Hicks in Buffalo, and a robbery that ended with the death of a Chinese food delivery man.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Two brutal crimes, one hard listen, and testimony that keeps tightening the screws on every story here.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on