Mums Mysteries & Murder · Marti & Cheryl

The Wanda Beach Murders

·1 hr 23 min·5 clips

Marty and Effie begin with casual chatter, a bit of timing panic, and the kind of ordinary update that makes the room feel small and familiar. They move quickly into the story of two girls who say they are going off for a short walk and then head up to the sand hills. A witness later recalls seeing them talking to a boy who looked around 16, with long blonde hair and light gray trousers. The hosts spend time on how normal that kind of encounter might have felt to girls that age. They talk through how teenage judgment, curiosity, and confidence can blur together. The boy later comes back out of the sand hills without the girls, which adds to the unease. The hosts keep testing details aloud instead of flattening them into a neat summary. That gives the episode a live, thinking-out-loud feel. Their reactions stay sympathetic rather than distant. They keep circling back to how young the girls were. The conversation keeps sliding between the case and their own memories of being that age. Those memories are not used to excuse anything; they are there to show how fast risk can be missed. The pacing stays brisk even when the hosts detour into side comments and mutual checking. The result feels conversational, but not careless. The case itself stays front and center even when the delivery gets loose. The tension comes from what is seen, what is assumed, and what is left hanging. The hosts do not force certainty. They let the strangeness sit in the open. That makes the episode feel grounded and human. It is a story about a seemingly ordinary walk toward the sand hills turning into something far darker. The show handles that shift with empathy and a little conversational roughness. The ending energy stays direct and communal, as if the hosts are still working the shape of the case together.

As heard by us

A conversational true-crime episode that turns beachside banter into mounting unease.

Mum's Mysteries opens with a relaxed, conversational pace that keeps the episode feeling close and unforced. Marty and Effie settle into an easy back-and-forth before the story turns toward two girls heading for the sand hills, a boy seen nearby, and the unease that follows.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a beachside disappearance told like a real conversation, not a script.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Mums Mysteries & Murder