Mums Mysteries & Murder · Marti & Cheryl

The Murder of Aileen Printie - Collab with Dawn from Scottish Murders

·1 hr 2 min·10 clips

The episode opens as a live, loose conversation at Killers and Coffee, with thanks to Katie from Airdrie Library and a brief note that it is the hosts' first time doing anything quite like this. One host sets out the Mum's Mysteries and Murder format, while Dawn from Scottish Murders explains her show and the kinds of cases it covers. The case is presented right away as unresolved, even though the conversation notes that some people see it as solved and others do not. From there, the discussion moves into Aileen's murder with a mix of reactions and explanation. The hosts keep circling back to the sense that police believed they were close to the answer. A cufflink becomes the central clue. They emphasize how distinctive it was, and how much effort police put into tracking it down, including public appeals and hundreds of photographs. The episode also spends time on the details around the cufflinks themselves. They were made in Birmingham and sold off in job lots in 1978 and 1979, with an Edinburgh jeweller confirming that two lots had been bought and sold at two pounds a pair. There were thought to be no more than about 15 pairs in Edinburgh at most. That makes the clue feel important without making the case any less maddening. The hosts stay animated and curious throughout. They wonder whether the owner of the cufflink ever came forward, and whether someone simply missed how important the clue was. They also raise the possibility that the man seen carrying an ice bucket and wearing a bomber jacket and jeans might not fit neatly with the cufflink evidence. The lead detective's public comments add to the pressure: the team was baffled, but they said they would get the man eventually with the public's help. The conversation also turns uncomfortable around the pressure placed on the family. The hosts make it clear they are uneasy with that part of the story and do not like how it was handled. That gives the episode a sharper edge than a straightforward whodunnit recap. The back half leans into speculation without pretending to solve anything. They consider whether the crime may have begun as a robbery, or whether someone knew Aileen was away and came to the house for that reason before things turned deadly. The episode does not force one answer. It leaves the competing possibilities open. What makes the episode work is the back-and-forth between the two voices. One tells the story, the other keeps pressure-testing it from the side. The result is chatty but focused, with enough structure to keep the case moving while still feeling relaxed and conversational. The hosts sound engaged, frustrated, and unwilling to smooth over the difficult parts. The ending comes back to the lack of certainty. They talk about how today's forensic technology might have changed things and whether more could have been recovered then. Instead, they are left with the same blunt problem: not enough proof and no real closure. The episode closes on that frustration rather than trying to tidy it away.

As heard by us

A loose but engaging unresolved case built around a sharp cufflink clue and family strain.

The episode follows Aileen's case without pretending there is a neat ending. Dawn from Scottish Murders carries the story, while the Mum's Mysteries and Murder host reacts alongside her, and the cufflink detail ends up doing the heaviest lifting.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want a chatty unresolved case with one stubborn cufflink clue and a very human, reactive tone?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Mums Mysteries & Murder