Morning Cuppa Hockey · The Nation Network

Conversation With Stefen Rosner Part 2

·30 min·2 clips

Matthew Schaefer's absurd 20-goal rookie season has the hosts questioning if he's the Islanders' MVP.

This episode continues the hosts' conversation with Islanders reporter Stefen Rosner about rookie defenseman Matthew Schaefer's historic season. Hosts Johnny and Colby analyze Schaefer's immediate impact and the Islanders' playoff push with Rosner, who covers the team closely. They debate Schaefer's award candidacy and what his performance means for the franchise's timeline. Schaefer scored his 20th goal of the season in a recent game, a milestone for an 18-year-old defenseman. The hosts describe his goals as involving fortunate bounces he earns by being in the right positions and getting pucks through traffic. They contrast the Islanders' current transition style under coach Patrick Wahl with the previous defensive system under former GM Lou Lamoriello. Rosner states the Islanders are among the league's best teams off the rush but need better breakouts. The conversation shifts to the trade deadline, with Jordan Kyrou and Owen Tippett mentioned as potential targets to add scoring. Rosner notes a potential trade for Kyrou might involve Brock Nelson and draft picks going to St. Louis. A surprising claim is that if Schaefer's team makes the playoffs, his Hart Trophy case should be considered similarly to Macklin Celebrini's situation in San Jose. The last defenseman to win the Hart was Chris Pronger in 2000. The hosts argue Schaefer is not just developing but is already a finished product, "bucking every trend" for a rookie. They credit coach Patrick Wahl for not sheltering Schaefer and for evolving his own approach after reviewing last season's games. Rosner suggests the Islanders' success accelerates the front office's need to support this core, stating, "why not go for it now." One memorable moment is a listener's question in the chat asking if anyone remembers legendary defensemen like Paul Coffey as rookies to provide context for Schaefer. The hosts conclude Schaefer is a "generational player" likely to be in the Norris Trophy conversation annually. They discuss the future captaincy, suggesting Bo Horvat may get it next before eventually passing to Schaefer. Despite the excitement, they agree the Islanders are not yet a true Stanley Cup contender, citing a need for more star power and a better power play to compete with Carolina or Tampa Bay. The tone is enthusiastic and conversational, filled with insider analysis and reactions to live game events. The style is a fast-paced sports debate, blending statistics, trade speculation, and player evaluation. This episode is perfect for New York Islanders fans and NHL enthusiasts interested in a deep dive on a historic rookie season and its team implications. Listeners seeking a broader league-wide discussion or analysis of other teams might find the focused Islanders talk too narrow.

As heard by us

A lively Islanders discussion that grounds Schaefer's rise in clear on-ice detail.

Morning Cuppa Hockey frames Matthew Schaefer's 20-goal season as more than a hot streak. It ties his rise to real usage, with top minutes and top power-play time, and keeps the focus on the steady impact he is making shift after shift.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want Islanders talk centered on Matthew Schaefer, press play.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Morning Cuppa Hockey