Monsters Among Us · Derek Hayes | Audioboom Studios

Crawling creatures, another man in the woods and a child with no eyes (Sn. 20 Ep. 34)

February 19, 2026·1 hr 5 min·5 clips
A mother and daughter encounter a boy with completely black eyes who stares with an unnerving gravitational pull.
Cassidy enters from Pennsylvania. Derek brings her in after saying the next report is not the usual strange lights in the sky. Her town is Tawanda, a small rural place in northeastern Pennsylvania that she says has a Seneca name connected to burial and death. That detail gives the story its first chill. Cassidy says the town where she grew up was a Native American burial ground, and that she has plenty of stories from there. Derek mostly steps back. He gives her a warm handoff, then lets her memory do the work without overselling it. The family history gives the excerpt its weight. Cassidy reaches back to her grandmother's childhood, when building houses and digging into the land could bring older remains up from the ground: skeletons, groups of people, and bones that had to be exhumed and taken away by someone from a university. Then the story shifts into the house itself. A later fragment stays inside a very old place, with the oldest part said to date back to 1697 and a later addition around 1817. The house is giving way. The roof has caved in, the doorway is low, and the old kitchen can only be seen through the damage. The hearth is still there. The floor bends inward like fingers after years of rain, snow, and weather have worked through it. Nothing feels staged or cleaned up for effect. The unease comes from age, family memory, and the sense that ordinary houses can hold more than they should. Derek's late-night-call-in style fits it. He lets the caller talk, while the show keeps layering place, history, and physical detail. The strongest moments slow down around land, ruins, and the feeling that the past has not stayed buried.

As heard by us

Pennsylvania burial-ground lore and a ruined old house keep the segment moving, even with the ad breaks.

The Pennsylvania call-in gives the episode its best stretch. Cassidy's account of Tawanda, the Seneca name described as meaning where we buried the dead, lands with real weight, especially when it folds into family stories about bones turning up after houses were built on the…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play if you want a caller-led story about a Pennsylvania town with burial-ground lore and an old house that still feels haunted by its own history.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on