Monsters Among Us · Derek Hayes | Audioboom Studios

A man-bird, disembodied body parts and lights in the windows (Sn. 20 Ep. 28)

January 15, 2026·59 min·5 clips
Alicia's pickle jar full of coins flies off her fridge by itself, with no one else in the room.
The evening begins with a jar. Alicia, from the Dallas area, remembers a house near Houston where sleep paralysis, recurring dreams, and a pickle jar full of change all seem to share the same charged air. Then Nate moves the episode somewhere colder. His call goes from moving objects to a figure that looks like his brother, floating nearly a foot off the floor and passing through fan blades without disturbing them. The shushing is the part that sticks. It is such a small, human gesture that the sighting stops feeling like a vague hallway scare and becomes something intimate and hard to shake, especially when the normal brother is there the next morning. The host does not push for a clean answer. He thanks Nate, talks through the messy overlap between astral projection, living ghosts, and doppelgangers, and leaves room for those labels to be circling the same thing. That is when the show works best: the caller gets the scary center of the room, and the host gives it just enough shape without squeezing the weirdness out of it. The episode also looks up. Positive Pete calls from California after seeing three brighter-than-usual lights near Moffett Field, where regular plane traffic makes the brightness harder to shrug off. Nothing in the transcript gets neatly solved. The fun is in the ordinary places going wrong: a vanity, a mini fridge, a hallway, a kitchen door, and a night sky near aircraft traffic. Even the host's tease stays low to the ground. Strange lights, ghostly body parts, UFOs, and a 50-year-old monster are promised with late-night calm, which helps the calls feel personal instead of staged. Some details may have ordinary explanations. Sleep paralysis is already in Alicia's house history, and Nate's later read borrows from the show's living-haunting and astral-projection archive. Still, certainty never shows up. This is a warm, caller-led run for listeners who like paranormal stories close to home, told plainly and left a little muddy.

As heard by us

A steady late-night run of strange encounters that stays eerie without tipping into parody.

Monsters Among Us opens with a jar of change launching off a mini fridge, then shifts to a transparent brother who seems to float, hush the narrator, and disappear through the door.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Need a night of eerie calls that still feel oddly human?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on