Rare Earths Reality: Hype vs Hope with 3 Experts

·1 hr 11 min·5 clips

China exported only 60kg of dysprosium to the US last year, revealing the heavy rare earth market's irrelevance.

The episode begins with the hosts expressing confusion over the mainstream hype around rare earths, prompting them to bring in three experts for clarity. Thomas Krummer, known as the Rare Earth Observer, explains that China's export restrictions on seven elements are likely tied to military use, not trade wars. He emphasizes that rare earths are not standardized commodities but specialty chemicals with unique customer specifications. Dylan Kelly, from Terra Capital, adds an investor perspective, noting the high capital and operational costs in the West compared to China. The conversation shifts to feedstock sources, with experts debating the viability of ionic clay deposits in Malaysia and Myanmar, highlighting environmental concerns like radioactive waste and low recovery rates. Thomas points out the inherent imbalance in rare earth deposits, where producing one element forces overproduction of others, complicating supply chains. The panel discusses the failure of Western projects to build downstream capacity, such as magnet manufacturing, and the reliance on China as a market for raw materials. They critique equity valuations of companies like Lynas and MP Materials, which are high despite poor profitability. The experts agree that Western efforts should focus on upstream mining and separation, leaving downstream processing to specialists. The episode concludes with reflections on geopolitical dynamics, the need for honest discussions about radioactive waste, and the slim chances for junior miners to succeed.

As heard by us

A clear reality check on rare-earth hype, supply chains, and the chemistry that can complicate projects.

Rare earths are now a mainstream market story, and this episode looks past the usual heat around export controls, headlines, and stock moves to ask what actually matters.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want to separate rare-earth market reality from the share-price frenzy?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Money of Mine