Moms and Mysteries: A True Crime Podcast · Moms and Mysteries Podcast

The Killing of Professor Dan Markel: A Family Feud Turns Deadly (Part 1)

·56 min·3 clips

A neighbor heard a loud bang, saw a light-colored car speed away, and found Dan Markel slumped in his garage.

1. Moms and Mysteries: A True Crime Podcast covers the killing of Florida State University law professor Dan Markel in Tallahassee. 2. Hosts Mandi and Melissa frame the case as local to Florida, with Melissa tied to Tallahassee as her hometown. 3. The episode asks how a divorce and custody fight around Dan Markel and Wendy Adelson became a murder investigation. 4. Dan Markel is described as born October 9, 1972 in Canada, with Jewish faith that stayed important throughout his life. 5. Ruth Markel remembers him scoring the highest aptitude result his school had ever seen in third grade. 6. Dan graduated magna cum laude from Harvard, studied at Hebrew University of Jerusalem, earned a master’s at Cambridge, and returned to Harvard for law school. 7. He later became a Florida State University law professor who published on crime and punishment. 8. Dan and Wendy Adelson married in 2006 and had two sons, one almost five and one three years old at the time of the story. 9. His living room had lines strung across the ceiling to display the boys’ artwork, and colleagues called him ambitious, witty, and self-effacing. 10. Wendy’s family is introduced as wealthy, tight-knit, and controlling, with Harvey Adelson, Donna Adelson, Charlie Adelson, and Rob Adelson at the center. 11. Rob’s relationship with his parents deteriorated because Donna and Harvey disapproved of his non-Jewish partner Hertha. 12. Rob says he married a Jewish woman from Dallas to appease his parents, then quickly annulled the marriage and returned to Hertha. 13. Rob tells investigators that when Dan was murdered, his stomach sank because he suspected his own family might be involved. 14. On July 18, 2014, a rented Toyota Prius followed Dan from Premier Health and Fitness on McClay Boulevard back to his Betton Hills neighborhood. 15. A neighbor heard a loud bang, saw a light-colored car speed away, and found Dan slumped in his garage with the engine still running. 16. Police later said Dan had two gunshot wounds to the head, and the autopsy found shots to the forehead and left cheek. 17. Wendy was interviewed for more than five hours, said "they're gonna think I did it," and described a Best Buy Geek Squad appointment and a stop at ABC Liquors. 18. The hosts point to Donna’s emails telling Wendy to "put on the performance of her life" and to use religion, money, and the kids against Dan. 19. They also describe Donna calling Dan "gibbers," a nickname the episode connects to antisemitic meaning and family hostility. 20. The show details how toll records, a rental contract, phone data, and an undercover FBI encounter with Donna pushed the investigation forward.

As heard by us

A conversational setup that makes the Markel case feel immediate without rushing it.

Moms and Mysteries treats Dan Markel's killing as a tight murder for hire story built around a family split, and the hosts keep it moving at a steady, conversational pace.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a warm true-crime setup that still keeps the stakes sharp.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Moms and Mysteries: A True Crime Podcast