Moms and Mysteries: A True Crime Podcast · Moms and Mysteries Podcast

Mindy Kassotis: The Navy JAG Murder Mystery

·49 min

In December 2022, a hunter in Georgia came across a body in the woods. At first he thought it was a wild hog. It was a human torso instead. The victim was identified as Mindy, the wife of a decorated Navy lawyer. On paper, he looked like the kind of man people would trust. In real life, he was living something else entirely. By the time Mindy's remains were identified, he had already changed his name. He had also remarried. The show follows that trail of lies as it comes apart. Mandy and Melissa begin with the strange discovery and move through the case step by step. They keep the pace brisk and conversational, which makes the facts easier to track. It also makes the deception land harder. Nicholas had been telling different stories to different people. He was presenting himself as a widower. That story was false. One of the women in his orbit, Samantha, believed she was building a life with a man whose wife was already dead. The episode shows how that version of events fell apart once investigators tied the remains back to Mindy. Nicholas was arrested in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, on May 12, 2023. That arrest was the moment Samantha learned that the widower story was a lie. The wife Nicholas told her died in 2020 was Mindy. And she was still alive when he first found his way into Samantha's DMs. She turned over her devices, messages, and belongings to investigators and later secured an annulment from the marriage. The hosts spend time on the fraud as well as the murder. That matters, because the story is not only about what Nicholas did at the end. It is also about how he kept control while keeping Mindy isolated and quiet. The conversation keeps circling back to the ordinary details that made the abuse easier to hide. There are practical lies, not just dramatic ones. There are name changes, moving pieces, and the kind of day to day manipulation that can look harmless from the outside. The episode never loses sight of Mindy as a person trapped inside that setup. It also makes room for how devastating the discovery must have been for the people around both marriages. The result is a grim, clear account of a case where the truth kept arriving in pieces.

As heard by us

A Georgia case told with warmth, timing, and an eye for the lies underneath.

The episode follows Mindy’s story in December 2022 Georgia, when a hunter found a human torso in the woods, and it builds around the decorated Navy lawyer who turned out to be her husband, living a secret double life.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

In December 2022, a torso in the Georgia woods opens a case built on lies, remarriage, and a hidden life nobody saw.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify