Moms and Mysteries: A True Crime Podcast · Moms and Mysteries Podcast
[It's Florida, Man: Toes] (Previously a Bonus Episode)
·31 min·1 clip
For $4,000, someone hired a guy to cut off his toes and eat them. It's Florida, man.
As heard by us
Carolyn makes the toe-cutting plan funnier by treating Phil's confidence like the start of a police report.
Toes finds its odd little charge in Phil asking Carolyn to watch him cut off someone's toes. Carolyn is framed as a former or current Orlando Magic cheerleader, and she has a broken foot in a boot, which makes the request feel even more specifically wrong.
Why you'd press play
Press play when you want a Florida story where a toe-cutting favor lands in Carolyn's lap and her imagination goes straight to prison, police, and blood at the door.
Listen to the show on