Moms and Mysteries: A True Crime Podcast · Moms and Mysteries Podcast

Daniel Brophy: "How to Murder Your Husband"

·47 min·3 clips

Nancy asked for a letter saying she was not a suspect so she could claim life insurance.

Mandy and Melissa open with a familiar chat about cooler days, Florida weather, and the hope of some fake snow. The conversation even wanders to a January trip to San Francisco and a daughter's sixteenth birthday before the case fully takes over. Then they turn to a romance writer's essay titled "How to Murder Your Husband." Years later, that same title sits next to a grim real-world death. Her husband, a beloved culinary instructor, is found shot inside his classroom. From there, the hosts lay out the clues that make the story hard to shake. Insurance policies come up early. So do gun parts. The timeline never feels clean. They keep circling back to how much time people had, what kind of gun may have been used, and who was nearby when it mattered. A minivan caught on camera becomes one more piece in the puzzle. The episode stays grounded by treating each small detail like it matters. Mandy and Melissa talk through the case in a warm, conversational way. The tone stays easy even as the facts get darker. Sponsor breaks appear along the way, but the hosts return quickly to the story. They also slip in a side conversation about money, children, and what it means to teach financial basics early. That detour leads to a pointed reflection on life insurance and the idea of not telling a spouse what policies exist. The close keeps the discussion personal and plainspoken. It leaves the listener with the uneasy sense that the most ordinary household topics can hide the sharpest red flags. The whole thing plays like two familiar voices sorting a disturbing case out loud, one clue at a time.

As heard by us

A classroom murder case built from money clues, bad timing, and ordinary life turned strange.

Daniel Brophy: "How to Murder Your Husband" starts with a grim, strange headline and follows the case through a classroom shooting, insurance policies, gun parts, and a timeline that does not quite hold together.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A kitchen-table true crime listen from Moms and Mysteries, where a romance-writer essay, a beloved culinary instructor, and a shaky trail of clues turn ordinary details sinister.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Moms and Mysteries: A True Crime Podcast