Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan! · Megan Owens & Mindy Johnson

The Murder of Ken Rex McElroy - Skidmore, MO 1981 - Small Town Vigilante Justice

February 23, 2026·50 min·20 clips

Missouri Mayhem returns to Skidmore, a tiny northwest Missouri town where everybody knows everybody else’s business. The episode starts with the setting, then lets the case grow out of that close-knit unease. Skidmore’s history of tragedy hangs over the story from the start, including the Bobbie Jo Stinnett case the hosts discussed earlier in the season. The hosts connect the killing of Ken Rex McElroy to the town’s wider memory of fear and unanswered questions. They place the listener in 1981, on a hot July morning when McElroy was shot in front of dozens of witnesses. He died slumped behind the wheel of his truck with blood pooling on the pavement. There was no chase. There were no screams. There were no arrests. The episode keeps returning to the strangest part of the story: almost 45 years later, no one who supposedly witnessed it has publicly said who they think fired the shot. That silence becomes part of the case, not just a side detail. The hosts move through the timeline without pretending the facts are tidy. They keep the tone steady instead of sensational. The episode also puts this story in a larger Skidmore context, reminding listeners that the town has already carried other dark headlines and mysterious deaths. The result is less about solving a mystery than about understanding how a community reaches its breaking point. The narrative is careful about what it can prove and blunt about what it cannot. It treats McElroy as a man who terrorized the people around him. It also treats the town’s fear as real and cumulative. The story keeps circling back to the cost of living with violence long enough to make people desperate. Even the unresolved ending feels deliberate, because silence is one of the main facts of the case. The episode closes by sitting with that discomfort instead of trying to smooth it over. What remains is a portrait of a town left in the uneasy space after a long reign of terror.

As heard by us

A grim Missouri story about fear, silence, and a town that never said who pulled the trigger.

Ken Rex McElroy and Skidmore, Missouri sit at the center of a grim story shaped by fear, silence, and questions that never settled. In 1981, a man was shot in front of dozens of witnesses and found slumped behind the wheel of his truck.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play for a Skidmore, Missouri true crime story where a 1981 daylight shooting left a tiny town, and a long silence, behind.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan!