MINUIT EXPRESS · Minuit

📣 SI VOUS L'AVEZ MANQUÉ l Meurtre ou légitime défense ? L’affaire Edith Scaravetti • L'Intégrale disponible 👇

·31 min·2 clips
Under ultraviolet luminol lighting, blood traces appear across the living room floor and furniture; upstairs Edith sees the rifle barrel protruding from her wardrobe and breaks down: 'Je suis un monstre, j'ai retourné l'arme contre lui' — then points at the ceiling where Laurent's walled-in body lies.
1. MINUIT EXPRESS presents the Scaravetti affair, narrated by Florent Houllier, exploring whether Edith Scaravetti committed murder or acted in legitimate self-defense. 2. The narrator is Florent Houllier; the episode was written by Luc Tailleur as part of the Crime, True History series produced by Minuit. 3. The episode asks a central question that French courts answered twice, differently: was Laurent Bacca's death an accident during a struggle, or a premeditated killing? 4. On August 11, 2014, Edith Scaravetti, 27, files a missing persons report at a Toulouse police station for her husband Laurent Bacca, 37, who vanished five days earlier after a morning argument, leaving no ID, bank card, or checkbook. 5. The narrator reveals that in the five days since Laurent's disappearance, Edith's three children have been able to play and dance freely at home for the first time in years — a detail Edith does not share with police. 6. Laurent Bacca is described as working odd jobs, drinking heavily, using drugs, and having a judicial record from 1997 for drug possession and dealing; he had not seen his son from a prior relationship in two years. 7. Edith eventually tells investigators she found an envelope connecting Laurent to a drug network and suspects he joined a go-fast narcotics route between France and Spain, involving high-speed border crossings with Moroccan resin. 8. Laurent's regular drug dealer, referred to as Nené, describes Laurent as a client spending 800 euros a month on cannabis and cocaine, who had asked Nené to find someone to assault Jean-Marie, an air center worker who had exchanged nearly 700 text messages with Edith in July, for 1,000 euros. 9. Three and a half months after the disappearance, police deploy a search team to Edith's house in the Saint-Simon neighborhood after neighbors and family note her withdrawal and changed behavior; on entry, an unbearable smell of death pervades the sealed house. 10. Under luminol lighting, blood traces appear across the salon floor and furniture; upstairs, Edith sees the rifle protruding from the wardrobe, breaks down, says 'I am a monster, I turned the weapon against him,' and points at the ceiling where Laurent's body is walled in. 11. Edith then provides full confessions and a life history: born to parents who almost did not have a third child, raised partly by a grandfather with Alzheimer's whom she cared for alone from age 16, dropping out of social life and school in the process. 12. She met Laurent at 17 at a party where both shared their wounds — his grief over his estranged son, her sense of lost adolescence; she became pregnant at 18 and he moved in. 13. After her grandfather was placed in a care home at Laurent's suggestion, Laurent became a domestic tyrant — refusing to share domestic responsibilities, drinking and using drugs heavily, exploding violently over minor provocations including a wrinkled shirt, a spider web, or the noise of children watching television. 14. Edith describes a decade of violence kept secret from everyone: broken arm explained as a fall, bruises explained as bumped walls; Laurent used a heated knife blade to brand his initials 'L.B.' on her breast and buttock, though prosecutors disputed whether the marks were self-inflicted. 15. In the summer of 2014, Laurent fired the rifle at Edith during a fight, the bullet lodging in the mattress near her head; she removed the magazine and hid the rifle on top of the wardrobe. 16. On the night of August 5-6, 2014, Laurent returned drunk at 3 a.m., attacked Edith, retrieved the rifle, threatened their eldest daughter, and dared Edith to pull the trigger; during a struggle over the rifle, a shot fired — Edith says she did not know a round remained chambered. 17. Edith spent the rest of the night in the locked bathroom, then in the morning took her children to the bakery and air center before returning to find Laurent dead on the sofa. 18. Rather than calling emergency services, she concealed the body — first burying it in the garden under the pergola, then, three weeks later when the smell became intolerable, moving it to the attic and encasing it in a concrete block between two brick pillars. 19. At her 2018 trial, psychiatric and psychological experts testified that Edith was psychologically incapable of forming criminal intent; the jury convicted her of involuntary homicide and sentenced her to three years, covered by pre-trial detention — she walked free. 20. On appeal in 2019, a different jury focused on the concealment, the physical effort required, and inconsistencies about timing; they convicted her of voluntary homicide and sentenced her to ten years, of which she served approximately eighteen months before conditional release for exemplary conduct.
Listen to the show on