Military History Club Podcast · Saul David

James Holland and Al Murray on Victory '45

·51 min·1 clip

SS General Wolf: Himmler's number two became a pragmatist—stealing art and trading generals for his life

Saul David welcomes James Holland and Al Murray to talk about Victory 45. The book is built around the end of the war in eight surrenders. They start with how the collaboration began. It grew out of Holland's earlier book on Arnhem and the 80th anniversary of the Battle of Arnhem. That gives the new book a wider late war frame. The conversation shifts from authorship to the conditions facing Allied planners in 1944 and 1945. The war is not simply ending. The Germans are being beaten, but the fighting in the Pacific is still expected to go on. The Allies are looking toward Japan and expecting another two or three years of war. That expectation shapes almost everything. Holland and Murray point to the manpower strain and the sense that about 800,000 men are still needed. They also talk about what happens once Germany is defeated. Redeployment becomes a real practical problem. The point keeps coming back that victory creates work, not closure. Saul presses them on the gap between military logic and political reality. They argue that armies can be defeated, but the end of war still has to be handled politically. They contrast the American Civil War tradition of defeating armed forces with the different task of overthrowing Nazi Germany. Stalin comes up as someone who understands the politics of Berlin very clearly. Berlin matters because it is tied to power and postwar leverage. The war in Europe is always being measured against the war in the Far East. That wider frame helps explain why Allied thinking in 1944 felt so compressed. The episode stays in the mode of careful historical discussion. It is patient with context, clear about distinctions, and willing to sit with the strategic mess of ending a war. It does not rush toward a neat conclusion. Instead, it shows how surrender, timing, and military exhaustion shaped the final months of the conflict. The closing exchanges return to the book and the hope that it does well. The tone stays warm, but the focus remains on the historical and political stakes.

As heard by us

A sharp look at how victory is negotiated, not just won.

James Holland and Al Murray use Victory 45 to widen the frame on how wars end. The discussion keeps coming back to surrender terms, manpower, redeployment, and the political calculus behind them.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the hard politics behind the end of the war in eight surrenders.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Military History Club Podcast