how GLEE saved Broadway | the stars who found stage success in the decade since the hit TV show

April 7, 2026·28 min·2 clips

How did a TV show about high school misfits become Broadway's secret weapon a decade later?

Glee's stage legacy gets the full accounting. The host starts with the almost silly premise of saying "here is what you missed on Glee," then puts the series back where it began, as a 2009 cultural phenomenon. The affection is there, but so is a little side-eye. William McKinley High School, the New Directions, and Will Schuster are used as pop-culture shorthand before the episode gets to Broadway consequence. Box office matters here. The host points to the buzz around Chess and argues that Lea Michele's Glee visibility is still helping draw attention in New York. Then the view opens up. Jenna Ashkowitz is the more interesting case because her stage life started before the television show, through Spring Awakening and childhood work in The King and I. Waitress gets room too. Her replacement run as Dawn counts, but the better point is that her producing work made her a multi-Tony winner. That changes the tally. Once on This Island, with Alex Newell in the cast, lets the host talk about Glee's Broadway afterlife as something bigger than actor nostalgia. The pace stays quick. He moves from current performers to the cast members who died before audiences could find out what their later stage careers might have looked like. That pause works. It keeps the fan frame from turning into a plain roll call of credits, and it lets absence sit inside the theatre record. Smaller credits still get respect. Diana Agron's Alexander McQueen play in London and Melissa Benoist's Beautiful run as Carole King both fit into the map. The episode cares about distinctions. One credit, a replacement role, a producing Tony, and a current Broadway draw are different kinds of evidence, and the host keeps sorting them. It is theatre criticism by inventory. The fun is hearing a solo critic weigh fame, training, stage history, and audience appetite without forcing them into one tidy thesis.

As heard by us

A Broadway roster check that turns Glee's afterlife into a sharper theatrical argument.

MickeyJoTheatre treats Glee's Broadway afterlife as a real stage-history story, not just a nostalgia loop. The piece frames the show as a cultural force whose alumni kept showing up on Broadway in replacements, revivals, producing work, and the occasional stage appearance.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want the Glee-to-Broadway roster, this one gives it to you cleanly.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from MickeyJoTheatre