Messed Up Movies

The Man With the Black Umbrella

·44 min·4 clips
A host who hates found footage calls this ultra-low-budget movie one of the most effective horror films he's seen in a long time.
Griffey brings Sam and Heath into a conversation about The Man With the Black Umbrella. Before things really get rolling, he warns the group away from researching the movie. That warning gives the opening a quick little spark. The panel compares the title to the black phone just long enough to laugh at how far apart the movies are. They remember seeing The Man With the Black Umbrella at Genre Blast Film Festival. They think the festival may have hosted its premiere, and they connect it to Ricky Umberger after meeting him there with Project Eerie. Umberger enters through that festival thread and through the panel's clear respect for his direction. From there, the conversation settles into the film's editing. A long opening shot lets tension stretch out. Quick cuts and intermingled footage keep the story alive when the slower material could otherwise go flat. The panel argues that found footage needs both rhythms. They compare the effect to the way Blair Witch and Paranormal Activity let a camera sit while still cutting to material that moves the story. One example follows the main character meeting with a detective. The character puts down the phone in a two shot, reacts to new information, then picks up the phone and aims it toward the detective. The panel reads that movement as editing done through acting. Another example has the character set down the camera, perform in front of it, and pick it back up to redirect the view. The discussion also notes the familiar issue of a character grabbing a camera just because something supernatural is nearby. They credit the film's narrative with making that choice feel motivated. Near the end, the panel praises the movie's price-to-value appeal and points listeners toward the show's Patreon, Misfit Parade, and Mr. Cream Jeans: Heidi Hole.

As heard by us

A focused found-footage review of the editing and camera choices behind The Man With the Black Umbrella.

Messed Up Movies treats The Man With the Black Umbrella as a compact study in why found footage depends on construction, not just immediacy. Griffey, Sam, and Heath keep returning to the film's long shots, jump cuts, and handheld movement, with particular attention to how a…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want found-footage craft, a Genre Blast discovery, and a camera that keeps turning into the problem and the solution.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on