Merge Conflict · soundbite.fm

507: iCircuit UI Roast: Toolbar, Popovers, and Polish

March 23, 2026·43 min·2 clips
Frank says iOS 26 makes `openURL` do nothing, even though it still compiles.
1. Merge Conflict 507 centers on iCircuit UI feedback, with James Montemagno reviewing Frank Krueger’s toolbar, popovers, and help links. 2. James Montemagno and Frank Krueger host the show, and Frank is the iCircuit developer whose app finances the conversation. 3. The episode asks whether iCircuit’s current UI choices are polished enough for iPhone, iPad, and Mac users. 4. James starts with the toolbar, saying it is crowded with a gear, a gallery label, a plus button, and a triple-dot menu. 5. Frank says the gallery uses Apple’s UI document browser and that the toolbar is constrained by the APIs he can add buttons to. 6. James then points out that the gallery and settings behave differently, with the gallery sliding up from the bottom and the gear popover animating back to the icon. 7. Frank explains that the gear uses a popover on iPad and a different presentation on iPhone, while the gallery is a page sheet. 8. James tests the gallery by opening it and downloading a circuit without signing in. 9. James says the iCircuit manual link fails after he moves to the settings area, which leads into the URL-opening bug. 10. Frank traces the manual to a web page on iOS and a bundled HTML help system on macOS. 11. Frank says `openURL` is deprecated and, under the iOS 26 SDK, now does nothing even though it still compiles. 12. James notes that the app logs no error when the manual and related links fail. 13. Frank says he should have migrated to the newer `open` API with options and a callback. 14. James raises a second issue about email behavior and asks what happens when Gmail is the default mail client. 15. Frank says the app catches exceptions and falls back to telling users to email him directly. 16. James and Frank then discuss sign-in and sign-out behavior for the gallery, including a case where the sign-in sheet closes without refreshing correctly. 17. Frank blames `Preclarum Forms` for not being able to refresh the form page without closing it first. 18. The tone stays technical and self-critical, with both hosts trading developer excuses and user-facing complaints. 19. Listeners who care about iOS UI polish, AppKit history, and app architecture will get the most from this episode. 20. People looking for general chat without iOS debugging details will probably skip it.

As heard by us

A focused UI debate that turns old APIs and phone-vs-iPad tradeoffs into tangible developer tension.

This Merge Conflict episode centers on a very specific developer grievance: the UI choices inside Frank Krueger's iCircuit, from the sign-in gallery to the manual and other links that can fail on phone. The exchange stays grounded in concrete details, which gives it real bite.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A candid iCircuit UI postmortem, with popovers, phone behavior, and old APIs in the crosshairs.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on