How much should doctors be paid? | BMJ Interviews Economist Richard Murphy

·36 min·3 clips

Junior doctors' pay has fallen 25% since 2008 while their costs rose 54%, creating an affordability crisis.

The episode begins with host Cameron Abassi introducing the topic of junior doctors' pay disputes and winter pressures on the NHS. Guest Richard Murphy, an economics activist and co-author of the Green New Deal, is welcomed. Murphy explains that junior doctors' pay has fallen in real terms since 2010 while costs like student debt and living expenses have risen dramatically, creating an affordability crisis. He discusses the BMA's use of RPI versus CPI for measuring inflation, arguing RPI better reflects housing costs doctors face. Murphy cites a BMJ-commissioned study showing a 25% pay drop and 54% cost increase for doctors from 2008 to 2023. He critiques arguments against paying doctors more, such as domino effects in the public sector, by pointing out market forces and competition for skills. Murphy then broadens the discussion to neoliberal capitalism, describing it as a system that extracts rents through mechanisms like high utility bills and pharmaceutical profits, contributing to inequality and ill health. He links this to rising NHS demand from issues like ultra-processed food consumption and poor management of neurodivergence. Murphy addresses young people's unemployment, noting rates around 10% due to an economy that fails to train and employ them, paralleling NHS staffing challenges. He emphasizes the need for upstream interventions in prevention rather than focusing solely on waiting lists. Murphy advocates for a mixed economy where the state regulates markets to reduce rents and inequality, potentially lowering GDP but increasing well-being. He references the Green New Deal and critiques GDP as a flawed measure, citing Robert Kennedy. In closing, Murphy prescribes a macro and political economy approach for the NHS, targeting causes of ill health like toxic substances and power imbalances in pharmaceuticals.

As heard by us

A resident doctors' pay dispute becomes a wider argument about burnout, illness, and what the NHS is expected to carry.

Resident doctors' pay opens onto a bigger health question in this BMJ interview: what happens when the economy that funds the NHS also leaves people too unwell to work?

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want to know whether resident doctors can reasonably afford a life, and why this BMJ interview turns that into a bigger NHS question?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Medicine and Science from The BMJ