Medical Liability Minute · Medical Justice and the Doctor Podcast Network

EP 93: Surgeon Unmasks the Unmaskable Defamatory Reviewer - How She Did It (Part 1)

·36 min·3 clips
She files a John Doe lawsuit to unmask anonymous defamers, starting a legal battle over IP addresses and privacy.
Jeff Siegel opens the conversation by framing Dr. Susan Schroeder’s experience as an odyssey through the online review world. Dr. Schroeder is a board-certified dermatologist and dermatologic surgeon with a broad practice, and the episode gives that background room before moving into the problem. The problem is anonymous reviewers, and she says she went after the people behind them with dogged persistence over the years. She reached out to Vitals through its contact section. The first reply said they were very busy and asked for three to four weeks, but a live person called back within four days. They reviewed the rating history and traced the activity back to 2010. Two IP addresses kept appearing again and again during that span. That detail changed the shape of the story, because it pointed to repeated posting rather than one-off complaints. Vitals said it would take the reviews down, but she told them not to do that yet. She wanted to speak with attorneys first because she was concerned about whether the data would still be available if the reviews disappeared. So she held the line. She also posted her own response for future patients, saying the account was currently under review. She was upset with Vitals and said so plainly, noting that the site seemed to allow posting from the same IP address every 30 days. Jeff presses on the practical next question, asking whether she tried to resolve it directly before taking a harder route. She did. The episode keeps returning to that tension between trying to solve a platform problem quietly and needing a larger legal response when the pattern keeps repeating. It is a conversation about evidence, persistence, and the limits of customer service when reputation is on the line.

As heard by us

A careful look at how one dermatologist traced anonymous online reviews back to their source.

This episode takes a plainspoken look at Dr. Susan Schroeder's account of dealing with anonymous online reviews and tracing them back to their source.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the play-by-play of how Dr. Susan Schroeder chased down anonymous online reviewers and pushed the issue into the open.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on