Matthew Cox | Inside True Crime Podcast · Rhapsody Voices

What Really Happened Between Tom Segura and Garth Brooks

March 11, 2026·1 hr·4 clips

An old talk-show clip has Garth Brooks saying, 'I'd rather kill somebody.'

The episode begins with a rumor that has already spread far enough to sound organized. The talk turns on a theory that someone has a chart matching Garth Brooks' tour stops to missing and murdered people in the same cities. The host is not buying the shape of it. He keeps asking for the actual list, who made it, and whether anyone can line up the dates without leaning on a lot of noise. The answer is messy. The guest says he spent time looking for the supposed chart and could not find it, so he made his own. He says he had AI pull Garth Brooks concert dates for a stretch of years, roughly 2013 through 2019, and then checked those dates against missing and murdered people on the exact days he was in those cities. He says about half the time there was a match and half the time there was not. The host immediately pushes back on that. Big cities generate a lot of grim coincidence. Chicago does. Detroit does. Los Angeles does. A date match is not the same thing as evidence. That point keeps coming back through the segment. The episode keeps separating a story that sounds neat from a story that actually holds up. By the end, the chart looks less like proof and more like a reminder of how easy it is to mistake a pattern for an argument.

As heard by us

A rumor gets tested against dates, cities, and the claim that the pattern proves something.

It tracks a rumor about Garth Brooks against the calendar, asking what remains when tour dates are lined up with disappearances and murders. The discussion works best when it keeps pulling the claim back to what can actually be shown, especially in the city-by-city pattern…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

When you want a rumor tested against dates, not vibes.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Matthew Cox | Inside True Crime Podcast