Matthew Cox | Inside True Crime Podcast · Rhapsody Voices

90 Day Fiancé Star Frames Boyfriend

·1 hr 53 min·5 clips

He says he was drowning while trying to reach Caroline, then touched her shoulder to stay above water.

Cole starts from the arrest itself. He says the whole thing began like a surreal misunderstanding, with paperwork that did not match what he believed had happened and with him assuming the mistake would get sorted out quickly. He does not stay calm about it. He remembers the mugshot, the holding cell crowded with people tied to Boca Bash and drinking-related boat arrests, and the immediate pressure of other inmates wanting to know what charge he was facing. The paper handed to him said felony murder. He says he looked at it and thought there had to be a typo because the accusation made no sense to him, and later learned jail paperwork can be wrong. That never really turns into a quick release. Instead, he spends the night trying to reach his parents, learning how recorded calls work, and hearing reminders that every word is being monitored. He says he had nothing to hide and keeps coming back to the feeling that he was honest from the start and still ended up inside a system that was moving on paperwork, not common sense. The other people in the holding cell add to the chaos. He describes them as mostly guys from Boca Bash, and when they hear the charge on his sheet, they start treating him like the big dog in the room. That joke lands badly. What he thought would be a quick processing delay turns into a lesson about how little control you have once a charge gets typed, printed, and passed around. He also talks through the girlfriend at the center of the story. She had been on reality TV, liked to repeat that bad publicity is good publicity, and was dealing with her own warrant or probation-related transfer from Palm Beach to Miami or Broward while he was stuck trying to figure out what would happen next. He says she got out the next day too. By the end, the conversation shifts from the arrest to what it does to a person afterward, including why he feels drawn toward defense work and wants to go back to law school. He says the experience changed how he sees clients. The result is a blunt, human account of accusation, confusion, jail procedure, and the strange way one bad night can reshape a life plan.

As heard by us

Cole's arrest story turns into a blunt account of how paperwork and panic can drift apart.

Cole's story follows an arrest from a holding cell to paperwork that turns out to be more fragile than it first looks. The best parts are the plain, step-by-step details: the crowded jail, the calls home, and the moment the paperwork stops matching the reality of the night.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a firsthand arrest story that starts in the holding cell and stays grounded in the confusion.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Matthew Cox | Inside True Crime Podcast