Matt's Movie Reviews Podcast · Matthew Pejkovic

Saturday Conversation - Paul Shirey

December 21, 2025·1 hr 29 min·20 clips

Paul sits down for a Saturday Conversation. The chat opens with his background as a U.S. Army veteran, entertainment journalist, accomplished artist, and content creator, then quickly shifts into the film memories that shaped how he sees movies. Early moviegoing comes up fast. Matt asks about first encounters with film, and that opens into a friendly conversation about how a movie habit can begin with VHS, move to theaters, and keep changing shape as the years go on. Physical media gets a fair amount of attention too. Paul talks about why owning movies still matters, even after buying the same title more than once, and the conversation lands on the familiar mix of annoyance and delight that comes with upgrading to Blu-ray or 4K for better cuts, commentaries, and sound. That leads into the collector's mindset. He jokes that a favorite film can turn into an expensive habit when every new format tempts him back in, but the point underneath stays serious: the ritual of collecting still means something to him. Matt keeps the pace conversational. Paul has room to explain why discs, extras, and editions belong to a larger film culture rather than just shelf clutter. The theater snack question gets a big answer. He chooses popcorn without hesitation and wants it drenched in extra butter, turning a simple preference into a small defense of moviegoing as ceremony. The answer stays playful. He also ties popcorn to nostalgia and to the bigger idea that the cinema should feel larger than ordinary life. The conversation briefly checks in on how often he has been going to theaters lately. Paul says the pace has slowed a bit, but he is looking ahead to a screening of Gladiator II and still treats the trip as something worth anticipating. Near the end, the discussion shifts toward independent creative work. Matt praises the panels Paul has shown, and Paul responds with gratitude and a clear respect for artists who make things outside the giant Marvel and DC machine. The ending keeps that spirit. It closes as a friendly, film-literate hangout that moves from memory to collecting to the simple pleasure of being at the movies, with a final nod to independent creators.

As heard by us

A warm film chat about collecting, movie memory, and the rituals that keep cinema alive.

Paul's episode stays close to early movie memories, the pull of collecting, and the case for physical media. Matt gives him room to work through how those habits form, including the familiar annoyance of buying the same title again for a better format, a director's cut, or the…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A movie-fan interview about childhood film memories, physical media, and why the same title can keep getting bought again.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Matt's Movie Reviews Podcast