Mark Leonard's World in 30 Minutes

Ceasefire in Iran

·32 min·3 clips
Mark Leonard witnesses President Trump threaten to destroy a civilization, then scramble to make sense of a Pakistan-negotiated peace deal with Iran.
Mark Leonard joins the conversation from Washington, DC, after several days spent watching the White House issue extraordinary pronouncements about the war in Iran. One of those pronouncements threatened the destruction of an entire civilization, while a peace deal was being negotiated by Pakistan between Tehran and the American administration. Leonard asks what that effort could mean for the future of the Middle East. American foreign policy and Europe's position stay firmly in view as the ceasefire is weighed. Asla Aydin-Tashbash, a Senior Associate Fellow at ECFR and a fellow at the Brookings Institution, provides the main analytical frame. Her answers move between domestic political pressure and regional power. She reads the crisis through the decisions facing Trump and the wider strategic consequences attached to them. Pressure from the MAGA sphere forms part of that calculation. Tucker Carlson, Megyn Kelly, and Steve Bannon are cited as people openly questioning the relationship at a moment when Trump is also managing pressure over Israel. Leonard asks whether Trump will tell Israel to stand down, tying that choice to the durability of the ceasefire. The Strait of Hormuz then becomes the conversation's clearest measure of leverage. Before the war, Aydin-Tashbash says, it was open with free access and freedom of navigation for everyone. Iran closed the strait when the war began, although some ships continued to pass through it. She describes the current arrangement as control by Iran and hardline elements including the Revolutionary Guard, which uses the passage as a tollbooth. That control gives Iran a possible revenue stream and a major deterrent because the strait affects the world economy. Aydin-Tashbash argues that the Trump administration considered multiple wartime scenarios without accounting for the immediate possibility that Iran would close Hormuz. Military plans for forcing a passage were considered, and Leonard compares the danger to Churchill's mistake at Gallipoli during the First World War. War planners appear to have persuaded Trump not to pursue that route, after which he challenged Europeans to lead the effort. That concern grows sharper once Trump asks Europeans to lead the operation. The ceasefire agreed by the American and Iranian teams included opening the Strait of Hormuz, making the diplomatic deal depend on the contested passage and its wider economic stakes.

As heard by us

A steady look at ceasefire politics, Israel, and Hormuz as a contest over leverage.

Ceasefire in Iran treats a fragile diplomatic turn as a test of pressure, leverage, and restraint. Mark Leonard guides Asla Aydin-Tashbash through the moving parts: White House threats, Pakistan's role between Tehran and the American administration, and the strain those choices…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want the ceasefire sorted through White House whiplash, Pakistan's diplomacy, and Iran's grip on the Strait of Hormuz?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on