Malevolent · Harlan Guthrie

Part 59 "The Vast Darkness"

December 27, 2025·1 hr 8 min·5 clips

Arthur says he wants his faith in humanity back, even while every offer in the house feels suspect.

1. Malevolent Part 59, "The Vast Darkness," opens back at Larson's Mansion with Arthur, John, and Lilith using the cold blue house as a staging ground. 2. Arthur and John carry the human side of the plan, while Lilith provides the cosmology, the rules around Cain, and the warning that time matters more than comfort. 3. The episode asks whether the lighter should kill Cain, trap him, or wait for a safer move. 4. Lilith explains that forces like Narlathotep are not bound by ordinary size, gravity, or human categories. 5. She says the manager made the lighter and that she did not use it earlier in England because ego clouded her judgment. 6. Arthur keeps pressing for a logical explanation, but Lilith insists that "death, primarily" is the right answer for Cain. 7. Arthur and John search the mansion room by room while trying to decide whether Lilith is telling the whole truth about her hatred of Cain. 8. Their suspicion shifts to the manager, because killing Cain would leave the manager as the last Narlathotep and possibly give him the Blackstone. 9. John points out that the manager once wanted the Blackstone and wanted to end the world, which makes the whole alliance feel like a possible con. 10. Arthur rejects pure paranoia and says he wants his faith in humanity back, even if the episode has given him plenty of reasons to doubt. 11. When they decide to tell Lilith their theories, the conversation becomes less about strategy than about whether anyone in the house is acting in good faith. 12. A locked bathroom and the lighter's light reveal a circular, gold-rimmed window on the wall. 13. Through that window Arthur sees a version of Faroe, older and angry, before the vision turns to her being shot dead. 14. John pulls Arthur back from the image and warns him not to lose himself in a scene that may be Cain's doing. 15. The tunnel sequence then pushes the same theme through a sheer drop, a drowning test, and a demand that Arthur choose whether to let go. 16. Cain treats the whole exchange as an illusion of choice, and the episode keeps returning to that idea as the characters argue over what is real. 17. A sudden shift to the future shows a snow-covered house, a roof-bound Cain, and a domestic scene with Faroe, Oscar, and Marie. 18. The episode's tone stays tense, talk-heavy, and theatrical, shifting between mansion arguments, dream visions, and stage-like confrontations. 19. Listeners who like cosmic-horror lore, faith debates, and pressure-cooker character scenes will get the most out of this episode. 20. People wanting quick closure or minimal mythology will probably skip it.

As heard by us

A cold, controlled confrontation that turns Larson's Mansion into a place for maneuvering and pressure.

The Vast Darkness brings Larson's Mansion back into a colder, bluer register, and the episode uses that setting with purpose. Arthur and his allies keep thinking in terms of time, distance, and position, while the rooms and hallways give them enough space to move, hide, and test…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a horror episode where every hallway feels like a test you were never meant to pass.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Malevolent