Reviews of the M4 Max MacBook Pro and M5 MacBook Air

March 18, 2026·1 hr 6 min·5 clips

Apple could sell 100 million Macs a year thanks to the $599 Neo, transforming their entire strategy.

It starts loose. Michael Simon, Jason Cross, and Roman Loyola drift through name jokes, schoolyard nicknames, and the physical-mail era of computer magazines. Then the laptop fight shows up. The panel treats Apple's MacBook pitch as a practical jab at people still buying cheap Windows laptops for ordinary computing. The iPad gets its lane. Apple sells plenty of them, but the group does not treat iPads as replacements for the machines people buy when they need a computer. The comparison gets hands-on fast. A Costco display becomes the scene: a MacBook near cheap Windows machines that seem competitive only if the spec sheet gets the last word. The hosts keep coming back to screens, flexy plastic, bendy builds, and the small moment when a computer feels cheap before anyone checks a chart. Specs still matter. They just stop running the whole show once the low-price PC and the Mac sit side by side. Then comes the Windows switcher theory. One host hedges that the numbers may be wrong, then says more people are probably moving from PC to Mac than the other way around. The panel largely buys it. A Windows desktop can still make sense for gaming, work requirements, or a second machine next to a Mac. The target here is narrower: Windows users who pick up a better laptop and feel the difference. The ending stays nicely untidy, with the comment and follow prompts giving way to an outro that almost trips over itself.

As heard by us

A practical Mac-versus-PC check that lands on feel, not just specs.

This episode treats a hardware chat as a larger consumer argument: Apple still seems to win on feel, cheap Windows laptops can look better on paper than they do in hand, and iPads have not replaced computers.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a grounded take on Apple's laptop pitch against cheap Windows machines.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Macworld Podcast