Dónde vivimos y qué tememos

·38 min·3 clips

Denmark lowered the age of criminal responsibility from 15 to 14, juvenile reoffending rose, school outcomes worsened — and the law was reversed.

1. Lo Que Queda del Día, hosted by Paula Molina on Radio Cooperativa, devotes this Friday episode to two separate expert interviews on housing and criminology in Chile. 2. The first guest is Javier Ruiz Tagle, director of the Instituto de Estudios Urbanos y Territoriales at the Universidad Católica and head of the Núcleo Milenio NuViv on housing challenges. 3. The episode's core thesis is that both housing policy and crime policy in Chile are dominated by political optics rather than evidence-based interventions. 4. Ruiz Tagle explains that Chile's housing deficit has not grown but has also not shrunk: the previous government's 260,000-unit emergency plan merely kept pace with new household formation driven by smaller household sizes and an aging population. 5. He describes a 100,000-unit overstock of unsold new homes coexisting with persistent unmet demand, calling it 'casas sin gente y por el otro lado gente sin casa.' 6. On the proposed IVA rebate for new housing, Ruiz Tagle says developers' own projections put the price reduction at 2-4%, far below the 15% figure cited in public debate, and notes it would primarily help investors rather than deficit households. 7. He argues that a blanket reduction in territorial property taxes (contribuciones) would be 'bastante regresivo' because it would deplete the Fondo Común Municipal, the main funding source for Chile's poorest municipalities. 8. On informal settlements (campamentos), Ruiz Tagle describes two extremes: the historically legitimized community-organized campamento and the newer narco-controlled 'loteos brujos,' with a wide range of conditions in between. 9. He cites Vienna, where roughly 50% of the housing stock is state-owned and residents pay no more than 25-30% of their income on rent, as the internationally recognized benchmark for affordable housing policy — but notes it took roughly 100 years to build. 10. On urban mobility, Ruiz Tagle mentions the Consejo Nacional de Desarrollo Territorial's '15-minute city' framework and argues that decentralizing schools and workplaces is as important as housing location. 11. The second guest, Felipe Estrada of Stockholm University's criminology department, opens by noting that in Swedish surveys 80% of citizens report feeling that crime is always increasing, regardless of actual trends. 12. Estrada states that Chilean homicides have declined for three consecutive years, mirroring a Swedish pattern, yet public fear and political pressure for punitive measures have intensified in both countries. 13. He argues that 'mano dura' policies — longer sentences, more incarceration, lower criminal age thresholds — perform well politically but that systematic reviews show they do not reduce crime incidence and increase rates of educational failure and re-offending. 14. Estrada cites electronic ankle monitoring as an alternative to incarceration that shows lower recidivism and better long-term employment outcomes across Nordic studies, at a fraction of the cost. 15. He describes a Danish natural experiment: when Denmark lowered the minimum criminal age from 15 to 14, criminologists found increased recidivism and worse school results for affected youth, leading Denmark to reverse the law. 16. Sweden is currently proposing to lower its minimum criminal age from 15 to 13; Estrada says this proposal has drawn criticism from all Swedish universities and the national legal review council. 17. He calculates that Sweden's planned prison expansion would consume the equivalent of 16,000 person-years of labor that could instead fund additional police officers, social workers, or teachers. 18. The conversation is conducted in a measured interview format, with Molina summarizing Estrada's points back to him and pressing on the tension between evidence and public opinion; Estrada's tone is analytical rather than polemical. 19. The episode is best suited for Spanish-speaking listeners interested in evidence-based social policy, urban studies, or comparative criminology. 20. Listeners seeking quick crime-news updates or practical housing purchase advice will find the academic framing too abstract.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Lo Que Queda del Día