Lively Minds, the UK Mental Health Podcast · Ellie Page & Will Sadler

S3E17 - Putting a patient-centred approach into practice, with Dr Alex Curmi

·42 min·3 clips
A psychiatrist reveals the limited but crucial decisions you must make when someone is in a mental health crisis.
Ellie and Will welcome back Dr Alex Kermie. They frame the conversation around how he helps people decide the best course of treatment, which keeps it grounded in real care rather than theory. He describes the range of rooms and environments he has occupied in his career, including physical health hospitals, inpatient wards, specialist clinics, and forensic work. He says he is drawn to novelty, and that moving between environments has helped him keep meeting new kinds of problems to solve. That range matters to him because treatment planning changes with context. The hosts then turn to resilience, and the discussion slows down on what people mean when they praise it. Alex pushes back on the idea that resilience should be treated as proof that someone is already fine. He says it can feel patronizing when people use it as a neat ending to a painful story. He is careful to distinguish between capital-T trauma and the voluntary stress that comes from stepping outside a comfort zone. The point is not to approve of suffering. It is to avoid underestimating human adaptability. Alex argues that language can shape what people think they are capable of. If someone is told they have reached their limit, that can become a ceiling rather than a description. The conversation then widens into the biopsychosocial model. Off air, and then on mic, the hosts revisit an earlier discussion about SSRIs and the familiar split between trauma-first explanations and biology-first explanations. Alex does not buy the binary. He wants a frame that holds body, mind, history, environment, and care together. From there, the discussion becomes more service-oriented. He talks about the importance of primary care, secondary care, and tertiary inpatient services all pulling in the same direction. He says those spaces work best when they encourage holism and an active disavowal of tribalism. The episode keeps returning to the same practical question: how do you make treatment feel useful, humane, and specific to the person in front of you? It closes on that patient-centred note, with the sense that mental health care is better when it resists false certainty and leaves room for complexity.

As heard by us

A careful look at how treatment decisions are made across different clinical settings.

This episode looks at how mental health treatment decisions get made when there is no single clean answer. Dr Alex traces the range of places and situations where treatment planning happens, while Ellie and Will keep the focus on the difference between resilience, trauma, and…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

For when you want a clear-eyed take on how treatment gets chosen, with therapy, medication, and context all in the mix.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on