Lively Minds, the UK Mental Health Podcast · Ellie Page & Will Sadler

S3E16 - How do we avoid overdiagnosis whilst respecting people’s experiences? With Dr Elspeth Davies and Dr Helen Salisbury

·32 min·2 clips
Helen Salisbury explains why the healthcare system incentivizes giving diagnoses even when they might not help.
Lively Minds treats over-diagnosis as a question of care, not a slogan. Will and Ellie open by asking how a diagnosis can validate distress while also becoming a label that changes how people are seen. They are joined by Dr Elspeth Davith, a medical anthropologist at the University of Oxford, and Dr Helen Salisbury, a GP and a columnist for the BMJ. Together they bring an anthropological lens and a frontline clinical perspective into the same conversation. The discussion starts from the idea that mental health language can slide toward medicalising distress. Rather than arguing for or against diagnosis in the abstract, the guests keep pulling the discussion back to what diagnosis actually does for a person in practice. They also ask what it does to the story around that person. Helen Salisbury describes how a diagnosis on a record can shape the way future clinicians read symptoms. If the label is wrong, the harm can be practical as well as personal. It can be hard to remove or revise once it has been entered. Elspeth Davith adds a broader critique of how diagnostic categories can separate people's distress from the circumstances that cause it. That separation can make suffering look private and medical when it may also be social or political. The episode keeps returning to the tension between access and pathologizing. A diagnosis may help someone get support or resources. The same diagnosis may also cast them as ill or broken. The guests do not pretend those consequences cancel each other out neatly. They let the contradiction stay in view long enough to matter. The closing stretch folds the discussion back into the problem of how to talk about over-diagnosis without dismissing people's suffering. The result is a conversation that stays humane, wary of easy answers, and focused on the real-world weight of labels.

As heard by us

A careful look at diagnosis as help, risk, and a lasting label.

The episode keeps its footing in a real tension: labels can open doors to care, but they can also stick in ways that are hard to undo. It treats that tradeoff plainly, without pretending there is a clean answer.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a clear-eyed take on when diagnosis helps and when it starts to harm.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on