Lively Minds, the UK Mental Health Podcast · Ellie Page & Will Sadler

S3E15 - School and Mental Health, with Caro Giles

·29 min·2 clips
Caro Giles describes how her autistic daughters broke down in a school system with no real provision for kids who can't manage.
Will and Ellie introduce Caro Giles as an author and teacher whose work looks closely at education and mental health. The conversation starts from the idea that many children are being asked to fit school in ways that simply do not suit them. Caro argues that the current system is not built for success or good mental health for very many children. She points to the expectation that some children start school at four and sit still at a table for long stretches of the day. She questions why stillness has become a condition for learning. The discussion treats that assumption as something to challenge, not accept. Caro describes how her daughter might have stayed in school longer if attendance demands had been lighter. She suggests that a reduced timetable, project work at home, or a more flexible arrangement could have changed the outcome. The episode also looks at the pressure local authorities face to keep children in school every day. That pressure can leave parents fearing fines or social worker visits even when they are trying to do the right thing. The result is a harsh double bind. Keeping the child in school can damage mental health. Keeping the child out can trigger official suspicion. Caro and the hosts stay with that contradiction rather than softening it. The discussion then turns to the way families have to prove need in order to get extra support. Caro describes the deeply unpleasant period in which a child may have to keep attending school and being traumatised so the system will finally accept that the situation is untenable. That process is shown as harmful not only to the child but to the parent carrying it. The conversation draws a line between institutional proof and human suffering. It also keeps the focus on the child’s experience rather than abstract policy language. Caro talks about the emotional cost of feeling like she failed when her daughter was not thriving in the way society expected. The hosts stay with that feeling and its long afterlife. The episode ends by returning to the central plea: listen to the child, and listen to the carer. Across the conversation, the emphasis is on fairness, specificity, and the gap between what schools require and what children actually need.

As heard by us

A thoughtful look at how school pressure and support hurdles can weigh on children and carers.

The episode takes on a hard, practical question: how a school system can ask children to fit a standard many cannot sustain, while parents are left to prove a child's need before extra support arrives.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If school pressure is wearing down a child and the person caring for them, this conversation stays with the hard parts.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on