Lively Minds, the UK Mental Health Podcast · Ellie Page & Will Sadler

S3E12 - Antidepressants, with Dr Alex Curmi

·48 min·4 clips
Psychiatry abandoned psychological wisdom to become 'real doctors' focused on chemicals, says Dr Alex Curmi.
Lively Minds opens cautiously. Will and Ellie say SSRIs are the most commonly prescribed antidepressants, make clear the discussion is not medical advice, and bring in Dr Alex Kermie to walk through the evidence, the risks, and the day-to-day reality of prescribing. The focus stays practical. Instead of forcing a neat verdict, the episode keeps circling back to benefit, side effects, and the need for regular review, especially when a prescription that began as a short-term fix has quietly turned into a long-term habit. That point matters here. The conversation returns to the idea, echoed by David Taylor, that antidepressants should be treated more like short, targeted treatments than background noise, with doctors checking in often and patients being encouraged to notice whether the medicine is still doing anything useful. The tone stays humane. Kermie argues that many people living with mild or moderate depression are not simply at fault or broken, and the episode leaves room for the harder idea that low mood can be a signal that something in a life or environment is out of place. Nothing gets flattened into a tidy talking point. The hosts let that idea sit beside the familiar clinical language of treatment, side effects, and patient experience, so the discussion can move between lived experience and professional vocabulary without losing its footing. There is no rush to wrap it up. The episode keeps returning to the mismatch between modern life and the environments it asks people to survive in, which helps explain why depression may need interpretation as well as treatment. The practical stakes stay high. By the time the conversation reaches long-term use, the real concern is less whether antidepressants exist and more whether they are being reviewed carefully enough once the first crisis has passed. The references are useful too. The show points listeners toward earlier conversations with Professor Joanna Moncrief and Professor David Taylor on The Thinking Mind podcast for anyone who wants to go deeper into the potential side effects of SSRI use. The ending stays measured. What remains is a case for regular re-evaluation, honest discussion, and a wider view of what depression is trying to say, especially when a quick fix would be easier to sell but harder to defend. For listeners trying to think clearly about antidepressants without sliding into alarm or certainty, the episode lands as careful, grounded, and a little more human than the usual script.

As heard by us

A steady, humane discussion of SSRIs, from evidence and side effects to why prescribing needs regular review.

Lively Minds treats SSRIs as a subject for careful judgment, not a clean yes-or-no answer. Will and Ellie keep the focus on evidence, effectiveness, and side effects, and they bring the prescribing question back to practice: antidepressants need regular check-ins, not default…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A careful SSRIs conversation for when you want evidence, context, and no hard sell.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on