LGC Investment Series Podcast · Local Government Chronicle

LGC Investment Seminar Scotland 2023, with Bruce Miller from Lothian Pension Fund

·16 min·1 clip

Bruce Miller explains how a 500 basis points interest rate spike has shaken pension fund strategies.

This episode features an interview with Bruce Miller, Chief Investment Officer at Lothian Pension Fund, recorded at an LGC investment seminar in Edinburgh. Host Martin George, Deputy Editor of Local Government Chronicle, speaks with Miller, who recently received a Lifetime Achievement Award. Their conversation focuses on the structure and challenges of the Local Government Pension Scheme in Scotland. Miller notes that while pension boards were introduced in the 2010s, Scotland still operates with 11 separate funds, unlike the pooled system in England and Wales. He states the Scottish Scheme Advisory Board is reviewing structure but observes no current "huge appetite" for pooling due to added complexity and governance layers. Lothian has instead achieved scale by sharing its 20-person in-house management platform with the Falkirk and Fife funds. Miller identifies climate change and the global energy transition as a primary challenge, describing it as a move from efficient fossil fuels to less efficient alternatives without all solutions ready. He cites rapid changes like a 500-basis-point interest rate increase and inflation as significant market issues. Miller expresses concern over portfolio concentration, specifically referencing the "Magnificent Seven" U.S. stocks dominating indices like the MSCI ACWI and S&P 500. Lothian Pension Fund has built an infrastructure portfolio exceeding one billion pounds since 2006, focusing on both equity and debt across various risk profiles. Miller directly addresses political pressure for local investment, quoting another CIO who stated pension funds exist to pay pensions, not to "level up" or fund specific private projects. On fossil fuel divestment campaigns, Miller explains Lothian's policy is not to exclude stocks, arguing portfolio constraints increase risk or lower returns. He provides a financial comparison, noting the S&P Clean Energy Index is down 12% over three years while the S&P 500 Energy Index is up 43%. He acknowledges fossil fuels still supply over 80% of global energy and that the transition will be gradual. The discussion is educational and conversational, grounded in Miller's long-term, practical experience. The tone is measured and analytical, focusing on fiduciary duty and investment theory. This episode is ideal for LGPS professionals, pension fund trustees, or anyone interested in UK public pension governance and investment strategy. Listeners seeking advocacy-focused content on divestment or local impact investing might find the fiduciary-first perspective less aligned with their interests.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from LGC Investment Series Podcast